ebucoreplus icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
ebucoreplus copied to clipboard

LocalGivenName for Agent class

Open tormodv opened this issue 4 years ago • 4 comments

To provide a given name in its local expression.

With the introduction of rdfs:Litteral as range language differences can be expressed with the ordinary fields.

"Liszt Ferenc"@hu "Franz Liszt"@de

Can we remove the localName variants?

tormodv avatar Nov 22 '21 19:11 tormodv

I think we should remove it. Should it be on the agenda of our next meeting?

aro-max avatar Feb 11 '22 09:02 aro-max

If it is about language versions, then probably remove would be correct. However, two thoughts on this: 1) some languages have multiple ways to present the same person, e.g. transforming Russian names from cyrillic alphabeth to western can be made in many ways and all are correct. 2) If it is about geographical names, then could there some case where the same person (or more generic any object) is know with different names in different regions? For example in product names car names of the same product are different in different regions….

kimviljanen avatar Feb 16 '22 17:02 kimviljanen

What you mention, @kimviljanen, is an excellent point. Unfortunately, the "localName" is not the solution, but we probably need to describe this. Searching for Пётр Ильи́ч Чайко́вский is, for me, very hard. I can't understand Russian; the English spelling is Pyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky, Pjotr Iljitsj Tsjajkovskij in Norway and Pjotr Iljitsch Tschaikowski in German. Sometimes even different traditions go even further, and variants can occur in the same language, like Пётр Germanized to Peter.

After much use of the delete button, it is time to add something.

tormodv avatar Feb 16 '22 19:02 tormodv

We have this construction, like a paperclip, that can be used between any two instances of any class. Skjermbilde 2022-06-04 kl  19 26 25

What if we make a subclass of this for linguistic relations?

@kimviljanen

tormodv avatar Jun 04 '22 17:06 tormodv