Treat ToString as casting to string in the database

[fingers10]

I'm trying to do a contains search on enum property in my DbSet and EF Core 3.1 throws the below error

The LINQ expression 'DbSet .Where(d => d.Position.ToString().Contains("acc"))' could not be translated. Either rewrite the query in a form that can be translated, or switch to client evaluation explicitly by inserting a call to either AsEnumerable(), AsAsyncEnumerable(), ToList(), or ToListAsync()

Entity:

public class DemoEntity
{
    [Key]
    public int Id { get; set; }
    public string FirstName { get; set; }
    public string LastName { get; set; }
    public Position Position { get; set; }
}

Enum - Position:

public enum Position
{
    [Display(Name = "Accountant")]
    Accountant,
    [Display(Name = "Chief Executive Officer (CEO)")]
    ChiefExecutiveOfficer,
    [Display(Name = "Integration Specialist")]
    IntegrationSpecialist,
    [Display(Name = "Junior Technical Author")]
    JuniorTechnicalAuthor,
    [Display(Name = "Pre Sales Support")]
    PreSalesSupport,
    [Display(Name = "Sales Assistant")]
    SalesAssistant,
    [Display(Name = "Senior Javascript Developer")]
    SeniorJavascriptDeveloper,
    [Display(Name = "Software Engineer")]
    SoftwareEngineer
}

DbContext:

public class DemoDbContext : DbContext
{
    public DemoDbContext(DbContextOptions options)
        : base(options) { }

    public DbSet<DemoEntity> Demos { get; set; }

    protected override void OnModelCreating(ModelBuilder modelBuilder)
    {
        modelBuilder
            .Entity<DemoEntity>()
            .Property(e => e.Position)
            .HasConversion<string>();
    }
}

When I query the table as follows I'm getting the error

try
{
    var test = await _context.Demos.Where(x => x.Position.ToString().Contains("acc")).ToListAsync();
}
catch (System.Exception e)
{
    //throw;
}

The Position is of type NVARCHAR(MAX) in my database.

This is not possible? If so please can you help me with explanation?

[ajcvickers]

@fingers10 This should work:

.Where(x => ((string)(object)x.Position).Contains("acc"))

EF Core then interprets this as a cast to string and generates:

SELECT [d].[Id], [d].[FirstName], [d].[LastName], [d].[Position]
FROM [DemoEntity] AS [d]
WHERE CHARINDEX(N'acc', CAST([d].[Position] AS nvarchar(max))) > 0

However, we discussed that it would be useful to allow ToString to do the same thing--it would avoid the non-obvious trick of casting to object. There is some concern that the output of ToString on on the client could be very different to what is generated on the database, but given the weak semantics of ToString anyway, that's probably okay.

[smitpatel]

Also see https://github.com/dotnet/efcore/issues/14205 Convert a different ToString represent can give incorrect results in query.

[fingers10]

@ajcvickers Thanks for the workaround. It works good and expected.

[Danevandy99]

I'm attempting to fix this issue. My goal right now is to have the p.EnumProperty.ToString().Contains("value") translate to a similar query to ((string)(object)p.EnumProperty).Contains("value") when the database type is a string, but build a case expression for database types that are not strings. The SQL for the second case (where the enum is stored as a number), would look something like this with Sqlite:

SELECT "p"."PostId", "p"."BlogId", "p"."Content", "p"."Title", "p"."Visibility"
FROM "Posts" AS "p"
WHERE 'pr' = '' OR instr(CASE
    WHEN "p"."Visibility" = 0 THEN 'Public'
    WHEN "p"."Visibility" = 1 THEN 'Private'
    ELSE NULL
END, 'pr') > 0
LIMIT 1

[roji]

@Danevandy99 please separate general translation of ToString() to a database-side cast (CAST(x AS nvarchar(max)) - which is what's tracked by this issue and what's already possible via (string)(object) - from any sort of enum-specific string conversion such as the CASE/WHEN you propose above. The latter is orthogonal to the former and requires careful thought (if you'd like to pursue this, please open a separate issue).

[Danevandy99]

@roji Sounds good! @ajcvickers mentioned this in his comment about the casting workaround above about how translating .Tostring() to do a database-side cast could cause unexpected results when compared to a client-side evalutation, but I can see how the CASE/WHEN conversion will require more thought and changes, so I'll make a separate issue for that.

[roji]

@Danevandy99 we had a thorough design discussion in the team about this, and came to the following conclusions:

• When ToString() is applied to an enum with the default map-to-int behavior (no value converter), we think it's a good idea to use CASE/WHEN to make the database return the .NET enum label. This is what we already do for ToString() over bool, and having ToString() return the number values as strings seems like it wouldn't be useful behavior for anyone. This is #33635.
• When a value converter is configured on the enum property, we should check whether it's our own EnumToStringConverter; if it is, we know what it does, and can simply return the string value from the database (we know it corresponds to the .NET enum values).
  • This intersects with #10434, and note that we don't currently do translation based on value converter identification. But whatever we do in #10434, it seems very unlikely that implementing the behavior described above would be bad etc.
• If the enum property has another value converter, we have no idea what it does, and can't provide a sensible translation. We should refrain from translating in that case (and the user will get an exception, just like today).

Does that sound OK @Danevandy99? If so, you can merge #33701 and #33706 together (close one and integrate its contents into the other - sorry for the churn), update as per the above, and we'll review.

[Danevandy99]

@roji That sounds great! I like the default case refraining from translating if there is no value converter or a value converter other than the EnumToStringConverter. I'll merge those PR's together and make the changes to line up with the behavior you outlined above.

[roji]

I like the default case refraining from translating if there is no value converter or a value converter other than the EnumToStringConverter.

To be clear, when there's no value converter, EF maps the enum to an integer in the database - for that case we'd do the CASE/WHEN. The only case where we should refrain from translating is when a value converter is configured, but it's not the built-in EnumToStringConverter.

[Danevandy99]

Yes, I stated that incorrectly, but I think we are on the same page. I should've finished my coffee before replying 😆