[Question]: Any issues with running on Podman?

[lessless]

Is your question not already answered in the FAQ?

• [X] I made sure the question is not listed in the FAQ.

Is this a general question and not a technical issue?

• [X] I am sure my question is not about a technical issue.

Question

Hey folks,

What's your experience with running Windows container on Podman? We are consider to switch to it from Docker and I wonder if that's a road full of tears.

Thanks!

[sladiri]

I just tried podman (again) and this time I did not have an issue connecting via RDP (#291). So in my short time I used it podman works fine rootless even. There is one issue I found but I am not sure if this is podman or maybe rootless related: #618

podman -v
podman version 5.1.1

Edit: need to check internet connectivity. Edit2: internet works fine. :)

[Nitrousoxide]

I've personally not had any luck with RDP connections, though it does sucessfully startup and can be connected through the browser based NoVNC.

This is my run command podman run -it --rm --privileged -p 8006:8006 -p 3333:3389/tcp -p 3333:3389/udp --device=/dev/kvm --cap-add NET_ADMIN --stop-timeout 120 dockurr/windows

Remmina just closes when I try to connect to it with this:

Gnome Connections gives this error:

I've also tried defining an explicit user with the env variables, and it correctly created it which I could see when connected via NoVNC, but it was (generally) unconnectable via RDP. I was able to connect to it once with gnome connections using that user's username/pass but after I recreated it I didn't work a second time. Remmina never worked in this case either.

I have a Windows vm on my proxmox server which Remmina can connect to just fine however.

[kimaung]

same problem. in linux it is very difficult to connect, but in windows it is easy

[Nitrousoxide]

same problem. in linux it is very difficult to connect, but in windows it is easy

I can also confirm that I can connect to the VM container with my phone's rdp client, but not using Remmina or gnome connections. I tried both the localhost path and the lan ip paths on the host machine too and I didn't see any difference, just in case connecting via lan worked but not via localhost.

[AkechiShiro]

Anyone has any clue why exactly there are some RDP connections issue on the host machine running the container with Podman specifically ?

Any way to move forward or pinpoint the issue here ?

[kroese]

Seems like a duplicate of #679