kitematic icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
kitematic copied to clipboard

v0.17.9 for MacOS is not signed

Open BetoFrega opened this issue 5 years ago • 10 comments

Expected behavior

App should open normally and without any alerts on MacOS

Actual behavior

MacOS displays a message informing that the OS cannot verify the app's developer and stops the user from opening it.

Information about the Issue

The App must be signed using an Apple Developer certificate.

$ spctl -a -v -v /Applications/Kitematic.app
/Applications/Kitematic.app: rejected
source=no usable signature
$ codesign -v /Applications/Kitematic.app
/Applications/Kitematic.app: code object is not signed at all
In architecture: x86_64

Steps to reproduce the behavior

  1. Download from GitHub (https://github.com/docker/kitematic/releases/download/v0.17.9/Kitematic-0.17.9-Mac.zip)
  2. Open on macOS Catalina

BetoFrega avatar Oct 22 '19 15:10 BetoFrega

I'm facing the same issue. Can't use it now.

JasinYip avatar Oct 23 '19 07:10 JasinYip

I confirm the same. Kitematic-0.17.9 is not signed nor notarized.

arekdist avatar Oct 24 '19 08:10 arekdist

@Trackhe that is a system bypass and should not be recommended.

BetoFrega avatar Oct 25 '19 18:10 BetoFrega

Docker Inc. recommends Kitematic and offers it as a download. They should have the resources to sign it, especially considering that they also provide Docker for Mac, which is signed. I understand that a lot of free projects can't (or don't want to - which is also fine) afford a Apple developer certificate. But Kitematic is supported by Docker and advertised as "by Docker" on https://kitematic.com - there should be a signed version available in my opinion.

One reason for example: On my corporate MacBook using Apps not signed with a valid certificate is forbidden for example, so I can't use Kitematic on it. And I guess other companies might have the same requirements as well.

schrej avatar Nov 13 '19 10:11 schrej

That's no reason to not provide signed versions of Kitematic until the Dashboard reaches feature parity. If they have something new to replace it that is ready to use, I'm fine with switching, but until then, a signed version should be provided.

schrej avatar Nov 14 '19 08:11 schrej

0.17.10 is also not signed. Latest signed version is 0.17.8.

apeeters avatar Jan 13 '20 10:01 apeeters

Upvoting this issue. Come on guys, it's been hanging for 3 months already.

adomasa avatar Jan 16 '20 17:01 adomasa

Problem still exists as of v0.17.11

huhlig avatar Mar 20 '20 02:03 huhlig

I am having the same issue with Kitematic v0.17.12 installed through brew cask install kitematic

oguennec avatar Aug 11 '20 14:08 oguennec

It's been about 10 months but this issue is still reporting. Currently docker desktop offers a dashboard so we can just use it instead of kitematic.

JasinYip avatar Aug 14 '20 02:08 JasinYip