decord icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
decord copied to clipboard

Identify new maintainer(s)?

Open leotac opened this issue 3 years ago • 11 comments

Hi @zhreshold and contributors,

Given that @zhreshold stopped maintaining this library, would it be possible to identify some trustworthy maintainer(s) that could at least update builds / accept PRs to fix bugs?

leotac avatar Apr 08 '22 08:04 leotac

(posting here to try to make some more noise)

This library is the best one I've ever used for this purpose, it would be lovely if @zhreshold and contributors could identify new maintainers.

ruancomelli avatar Jun 16 '22 12:06 ruancomelli

Anyone interested? Currently I cannot allocate enough time for new features/bug fixes, but I could still review PRs and get involved in discussions.

zhreshold avatar Jul 19 '22 08:07 zhreshold

I can help maintain this project. I've hacked it pretty much to fix multiple bugs. I'm working on another project (EVA-DB) which is an AI-Relational Database System. I was hoping that I could merge my changes and help fix some bugs, and also want to use decord for the other project. We can talk, @zhreshold ?

gaurav274 avatar Mar 18 '23 23:03 gaurav274

This repo remains the best tool for it's intended purpose. I use it for continuous frame seeking with a buffer (here). There are 1.9K projects that use decord as a dependency, which is incredible.

I'm starting to bump into some serious bugs that require knowledgeable maintainers. Is there a path to active maintenance? Is there something that a layman can help with to achieve this?

https://github.com/ralphtheninja/open-funding#grants https://github.com/nayafia/lemonade-stand

RichieHakim avatar Feb 27 '24 22:02 RichieHakim

@gaurav274 @zhreshold I'm happy to also put anyone in contact with some people who can help try to acquire funds from CZI's grants for research software in computer vision.

The value and utility of this repo is evident in the outstanding issues and huge userbase.

RichieHakim avatar Mar 25 '24 04:03 RichieHakim

@RichieHakim, I've got the bandwidth to help maintain this project. However, I've been unable to contact @zhreshold. I'm not sure how we can move forward.

gaurav274 avatar Mar 25 '24 20:03 gaurav274

@gaurav274 (@zhreshold)

  1. Maybe ping his linkedin?
  2. The dmlc governance / structure seems to have disappeared (at least publicly). It has sort of drifted into a distributed group of people maintaining xgboost and and dgl. I've been using your eva-decord repo since mac-12.0.

RichieHakim avatar Mar 25 '24 21:03 RichieHakim

@RichieHakim Unfortunately, I haven't heard back from @zhreshold. I tried reaching out via LinkedIn as well. Does it make sense to create a fork and maintain that?

gaurav274 avatar May 01 '24 20:05 gaurav274

Yes, I think it's safe to assume @zhreshold has moved on. I'm throwing out some hail mary messages in slacks and emails, but I'm not very optimistic about them. I also took the liberty of CC'ing you and making some assumptions, sorry if that I presumed incorrectly. I'll try a bit longer to get in touch with DMLC organizers so that you (and maybe I) can be made a maintainer. That would be best. If there is no movement on that, then yes a fork will be necessary. Maybe give it a week or two?

RichieHakim avatar May 01 '24 21:05 RichieHakim

Hi @gaurav274 . I just want to make sure you saw the email by TQ. They have been going to what I believe is your gmail address. If not let me know. We have a meeting with him on Weds at 1pm.

RichieHakim avatar May 04 '24 17:05 RichieHakim

Hi @RichieHakim, thanks for leading the mail thread. Yup, I got the emails. I’ll block my calendar. Btw, please specify the time zone. Thanks!

gaurav274 avatar May 05 '24 04:05 gaurav274