`Select`s not working in `Modal`s on mobile, works on desktop

[Pirulax]

Description

Select inputs dont appear in modals on mobile at all, while they work just fine on desktop

Steps to Reproduce

Send a modal with a select. I'm using Discord.py so I have no clue how the raw payload looks like, so I can't post it. If it matters, I'm sending the Modal as a response to a Button interaction.

Expected Behavior

The Modal to appear as it does on Desktop

Current Behavior

Select doesn't appear

Screenshots/Videos

Image

Client and System Information

I'm using Discord.py, latest. Desktop is Windows 10 latest build, phones are (tested on multiple) Samsung S20+, iPhone 11/12 (Not sure which iOS), all show the same issue.

[advaith1]

Select menus are not supported in modals. This is not a bug.

[Pirulax]

That's weird. They work perfectly fine on Desktop. I wonder why they wouldn't be supported? Super nice feature to have.

[IanMitchell]

These aren't currently supported because they don't work on Mobile 😛.

[Pirulax]

Okay, but they will be supported, as I understand? Someone people have told me they aren't supported at all (implying it won't be supported either).

[IanMitchell]

Eventually we do plan on adding selects to modals, but there is no timeline on when that will happen and we are not actively working on it.

[Pirulax]

Well, that is a bummer, it was super useful :( Now I had to resort to a really ugly (it was already ugly because sending a modal after a modal is not possible, which I had to do, because I had more than 5 items to be sent).

[timka-123]

Select menus are not supported in modals. This is not a bug.

but why it works?

[Smidul]

but why it works?

it doesn't anymore, they fixed it

[Pirulax]

Yeah it used to work on desktop (when I opened the ticket), then they removed it...