MODiX icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
MODiX copied to clipboard

Proposal: Raid Detection

Open JakenVeina opened this issue 6 years ago • 3 comments

This proposal is to implement some kind of raid detection in MODiX, which can automatically issue an @Staff notification in #mod-log if it detects a potential raid.

The criteria for defining the start of a raid, and end of a raid, are obviously the most interesting part about this proposal. My initial thoughts are...

  1. If a certain number of users have joined the server, within a certain timeframe. Say, 10 people in 30 seconds, for example.
  2. Potentially, a lower threshold, for users that were created briefly before joining.
  3. Once a notification has been issued, there would need to be a cooldown to prevent repeats during the raid. Say, "once an hour has passed with no new users joining".

JakenVeina avatar Aug 05 '18 04:08 JakenVeina

Should post straight to #moderation and ping all Staff.

The raid mode should be initiated manually only and will lock down all channels to >= regular with an automatic message posted to general.

Raid mode automatically get's turned off an hour in, or earlier with staff intervention.

patrickklaeren avatar Aug 05 '18 16:08 patrickklaeren

There is also the possiblity to switch new comers to an "overflow channel", which is usually notavailable.

Instead of just locking all the channels, we could redirect any newcomers to that channel. Lock that down for comments and let only users with roles write in there. Idk if thats feasable.

Preferably all the other channels with existing users and discussions are unaffected.

Insire avatar Aug 05 '18 16:08 Insire

There's a lot of different ways we could handle the actual !raidmode command, and yeah, it should definitely be staff-initiated.

All I'm worried about in this issue is the potential to auto-notify staff that intervention might be needed.

See #135, #136

JakenVeina avatar Aug 05 '18 19:08 JakenVeina

This issue is made obsolete by Discord's own implementation of raid detection.

Suggested action: Close issue.

thaumanovic avatar Jun 19 '23 20:06 thaumanovic

Agreed, aside from Discord's built-in raid detection, Accord has also been meeting our needs in this respect pretty well so far.

Closing for now, but we can revisit if the existing solutions aren't cutting it later.

Scott-Caldwell avatar Jun 19 '23 21:06 Scott-Caldwell