didc Rust output not generating records not referenced in service

[lastmjs]

didc is not generating Rust structs for records that aren't referenced from a service. This is undesirable for my use case, as I have Candid-defined records that may not be used in exported query or update functions, but which are needed to do cross-canister calls for example.

This Candid file:

type CanisterStatusArgs = record {
    "canister_id": text;
};

type CanisterStatusResult = record {
    "cycles": float64;
};

service: {
    "initiateTransfer": () -> (int32);
    "randomness": () -> (vec nat8);
    "status": () -> (float64);
}

generates this Rust code with didc bind [path-to-did] -t rs:

// This is an experimental feature to generate Rust binding from Candid.
// You may want to manually adjust some of the types.
use ic_cdk::export::candid::{self, CandidType, Deserialize};
use ic_cdk::api::call::CallResult;

struct SERVICE(candid::Principal);
impl SERVICE{
  pub async fn initiateTransfer(&self) -> CallResult<(i32,)> {
    ic_cdk::call(self.0, "initiateTransfer", ()).await
  }
  pub async fn randomness(&self) -> CallResult<(Vec<u8>,)> {
    ic_cdk::call(self.0, "randomness", ()).await
  }
  pub async fn status(&self) -> CallResult<(f64,)> {
    ic_cdk::call(self.0, "status", ()).await
  }
}

Notice that the CanisterStatusArgs and CanisterStatusResult records have not be translated into Rust structs.

But if you run didc bind [path-to-did] -t rs with this Candid:

type CanisterStatusArgs = record {
    "canister_id": text;
};

type CanisterStatusResult = record {
    "cycles": float64;
};

you do get the Rust structs:

// This is an experimental feature to generate Rust binding from Candid.
// You may want to manually adjust some of the types.
use ic_cdk::export::candid::{self, CandidType, Deserialize};
use ic_cdk::api::call::CallResult;

#[derive(CandidType, Deserialize)]
struct CanisterStatusArgs { canister_id: String }

#[derive(CandidType, Deserialize)]
struct CanisterStatusResult { cycles: f64 }

I would like the Rust structs to always be generated.

[lastmjs]

I've observed that didc bind [path-to-did] -t ts correctly outputs the records not referenced in the service:

import type { Principal } from '@dfinity/principal';
export interface CanisterStatusArgs { 'canister_id' : string }
export interface CanisterStatusResult { 'cycles' : number }
export interface _SERVICE {
  'initiateTransfer' : () => Promise<number>,
  'randomness' : () => Promise<Array<number>>,
  'status' : () => Promise<number>,
}

as does didc bind [path-to-did] -t mo:

// This is a generated Motoko binding.
// Please use `import service "ic:canister_id"` instead to call canisters on the IC if possible.

module {
  public type CanisterStatusArgs = { canister_id : Text };
  public type CanisterStatusResult = { cycles : Float };
  public type Self = actor {
    initiateTransfer : shared () -> async Int32;
    randomness : shared () -> async [Nat8];
    status : shared () -> async Float;
  }
}

[chenyan-dfinity]

Right. Both JS and Rust binding only generate types referenced in the service. Because both languages require identification of recursion points, and that algorithm requires sorting the type definitions from a root. I will have to think about if that can be relaxed.

A workaround is to separate the type definition in another did file without the main actor.

[lastmjs]

func types are also not generated if not referenced in the service.