thumb-key icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
thumb-key copied to clipboard

Inserting a space and then typing a period should backspace the space before typing the period

Open DeflateAwning opened this issue 1 year ago • 11 comments

DeflateAwning avatar Apr 18 '23 07:04 DeflateAwning

I'm not sure I follow. Using the clause-ending spacebar multitaps, tapping the spacebar 3 times should do a period thes a space, so it can start the new sentence.

dessalines avatar Apr 18 '23 11:04 dessalines

What I meant was, say I type "Some words " (note the space after the words). Now I decide I want to type a period. If I type a period now, the next turns in to "Some words ." (note the space between the words and the period. The functionality of other virtual keyboards is to automatically remove the space, so the typed text becomes "Some words." (which is how you would generally want it to be).

If you actually want to type "Some words ." for some reason, then you have to type "Some words." (note the two spaces).

I'd suggest this should be default behavior, but maybe there should be a setting to disable it if people don't like it

DeflateAwning avatar Apr 18 '23 16:04 DeflateAwning

Agreed, that sounds useful.

skorokithakis avatar Apr 26 '23 18:04 skorokithakis

This seems not-explicit behavior. There are many cases where you might want a period after a space, such as when you use parentheses like some text (some other text) .

If someone really wants this, I'd accept a PR to add that setting, but it seems easier to me to just tap backspace.

dessalines avatar May 21 '23 16:05 dessalines

Why would someone want to type "some text (some other text) ." I've wanted to type NOT that (i.e., no space) 100x more than I've wanted to type that.

You can still type it your way; you just have to put an extra space. PR incoming; can you please re-open the issue?

DeflateAwning avatar May 22 '23 00:05 DeflateAwning

If this is added, please make it an option rather than forced. On the previous keyboard I used, it was very annoying that it autocorrected "sometext : )" to "sometext: )" because of removing pre-punctuation spaces. Even if this only applies to periods, I'd actually much prefer to see Thumb-Key stay as simple as possible with as little auto/"error" correction as possible, trusting the user to know what they're doing.

xxxxme avatar Jun 10 '23 14:06 xxxxme

It would only be for periods and commas. Please give an example of a time you've ever intended to insert a space between a letter and a period/comma.

DeflateAwning avatar Jun 10 '23 18:06 DeflateAwning

If it's only for periods and commas, I would not object ,.';.;'.,

xxxxme avatar Jun 14 '23 13:06 xxxxme

Would still like this feature!

DeflateAwning avatar Oct 15 '23 23:10 DeflateAwning

Chiming in with example usecase for leaving the space, since others seem confused why this should be optional.

When discussing programming or talking about shell commands (eg in github comments!) I often need to say things like

Select x
, y
, z
From table

Or run ls -l .

BlueDrink9 avatar Feb 06 '24 23:02 BlueDrink9

Programming is so different from regular language typing, that it seems like turning off multitaps (and probably autocapitalize) is the best option.

The alternative is to add all kinds of settings for multitap exceptions and intracacies.

dessalines avatar Feb 07 '24 17:02 dessalines

Its been a year and no one wanted to work on this. If anyone's willing, I'll re-open and assign it to them.

dessalines avatar Feb 12 '25 22:02 dessalines