Deepthi Sigireddi

> I'm not sure what elevates a proposal to VEP status We haven't discussed that, and so far we have had VEPs only for Release cycle and upgrade order. Functional...

Hmm.. looking at the example from vitess repo https://github.com/vitessio/vitess/blob/main/examples/operator/201_customer_tablets.yaml#L70 It looks like we are running vtorc only for the commerce keyspace and not for the customer keyspace. Is this by...

@L3o-pold can you please capture the log from vttablet as well? None of us maintainers have access to a minio environment so this will be tough to debug.

Our minio dependency hasn't changed in years. However the `aws-sdk-go` dependency has changed. That would be the first place to check. https://github.com/vitessio/vitess/blame/main/go.mod#L14 You can see the diff here https://github.com/vitessio/vitess/commit/9d2029aff8a805c6f646eef47e1b90c76f80d3e9 If...

I'm going to test with vanilla S3 to see if that exhibits the same problem. If yes, we will have to revert at least a portion of #12500 and then...

I have tested PR #12500 (or actually it's exact counterpart on the planetscale fork) and backups with vanilla S3 work just fine. However, my test db is very small, and...

@L3o-pold can you try if builtinbackup works? You did specify the flags in your issue description but I missed the fact that you are in fact using xtrabackup. My test...

@L3o-pold there are 3 variables here - vanilla s3 vs your storage - builtinbackup vs xtrabackup -> you have shown that this doesn't matter - vtctlclient vs vtctldclient - can...

I just tried the same thing against s3 (without --allow_primary, so it happened on a replica) and the backup succeeds. So at this point I'm going say that this seems...

In order to scope this down a bit further we can try this - my test was with the PlanetScale fork, I can re-test with vanilla vitess - is it...