datanucleus-core icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
datanucleus-core copied to clipboard

Change the L2 maxSize behavior to evict idle entries

Open nekhtan opened this issue 1 year ago • 1 comments

Hello,

It seems that the datanucleus.cache.level2.maxsize feature is only preventing the cache from storing more objects once it reaches the defined limit. Would that be possible to change this behavior so that it starts evicting idle entries when the threshold is near (or even reached if it's easier to do) ?

Also, looking at the AbstractReferencedLevel2Cache, since the putAll method does not implement the maxSize feature and the put method checks for equality, isn't it possible that even the implemented feature (on the put) is broken because the threshold is exceeded following a call to putAll ?

Example:

  • maxSize=10
  • put(1) -> ok - size = 1
  • put(1) -> ok - size = 2
  • putAll(10) -> ok - size = 12
  • put(1) -> ok -> should have been rejected, right ?

Thanks in advance for your insight !

nekhtan avatar Jun 28 '24 14:06 nekhtan

Thanks for your comments. You are welcome to contribute a proposed improvement to the handling, via a pull request. Yes, the current maxSize handling is simple; it provides a reference for people to improve upon for their specific situation. When we have a better implementation that can become the default.

I don't see anything broken in the current implementation on the face of it. putAll(10) in your example will try to put each of the 10 new objects one by one and will be successful with the first 8 until size() reaches 10. The last 2 will be rejected.

andyjefferson avatar Aug 24 '24 15:08 andyjefferson