dat-desktop icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
dat-desktop copied to clipboard

add replication percentage

Open juliangruber opened this issue 8 years ago • 15 comments

This is something only we can offer, so it would be cool to show off with it! For a dat that you're sharing, it would be awesome to show how much of it is replicated in the entire network. So say the replication percentage is 50%, that would mean that half of the dat's data is already available from other peers.

juliangruber avatar Apr 06 '17 11:04 juliangruber

This gives us another dimension for a dat's health, and is just super handy in general.

juliangruber avatar Apr 06 '17 11:04 juliangruber

Yeah sounds cool, think this would tie into a "details" view (#260) - probably need that detail view for metadata editing anyway (grant requirement) so could be a cool bonus

yoshuawuyts avatar Apr 06 '17 11:04 yoshuawuyts

What about instead, this is another dimension on top of the progress bar? When you're sharing a dat that you already have locally, the progress bar is kind of useless anyways:

screen shot 2017-04-06 at 13 59 14

So instead, we could use a different shade of green to render a progress bar of "replication progress" "on top".

juliangruber avatar Apr 06 '17 11:04 juliangruber

@juliangruber interesting, sounds like you're right and there's def options there - think @Kriesse could best answer how / what about this

yoshuawuyts avatar Apr 06 '17 12:04 yoshuawuyts

I like it! We could show a darker green bar on top of your local 100% green bar. But it's a concept that is not very intuitive and won't be clear just from the viusals or labels, so we'd need a tiny "?" icon next to it, that would explain it.

Kriesse avatar Apr 06 '17 12:04 Kriesse

so we'd need a tiny "?" icon next to it, that would explain it.

sgtm!

juliangruber avatar Apr 06 '17 12:04 juliangruber

let's work on this once the edit in place feature landed :)

juliangruber avatar Apr 06 '17 12:04 juliangruber

👍

Kriesse avatar Apr 06 '17 12:04 Kriesse

Mockup

image

image

Kriesse avatar Apr 06 '17 12:04 Kriesse

@juliangruber does this make sense? (The copy in the tooltip is awkward, need to improve that.)

Kriesse avatar Apr 06 '17 12:04 Kriesse

Copy idea: "20% of the data is currently not available on the network" where s/20%/the actual value/ - that way people get more exact details, and start relating the grayed out area with data not yet being available - kinda useful for both beginners and power users

On Thu, Apr 6, 2017 at 2:44 PM Kristina Schneider [email protected] wrote:

@juliangruber https://github.com/juliangruber does this make sense? (The copy in the tooltip is awkward, need to improve that.)

— You are receiving this because you commented.

Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/datproject/dat-desktop/issues/327#issuecomment-292162544, or mute the thread https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/ACWlehR_m5yDI1ZQ_6dpXq2bOlCCjSHUks5rtN48gaJpZM4M1ftK .

yoshuawuyts avatar Apr 06 '17 13:04 yoshuawuyts

ah, yeah this is the case where you don't have everything yet, that makes sense too!

juliangruber avatar Apr 06 '17 13:04 juliangruber

Did any users say they needed this?

okdistribute avatar Apr 06 '17 17:04 okdistribute

not that i'm aware of, but also not that they were aware of this being possible.

i as a user would like this feature.

juliangruber avatar Apr 06 '17 17:04 juliangruber

Can we prioritize the history and selective download and put this on the backburner? Unless at least a few of our users ask for it (we don't count as users :P)

okdistribute avatar May 02 '17 18:05 okdistribute