Daniel House @ Seeking Opportunities

> If we want to do something like the [Redis cluster v2](https://github.com/redis/redis/blob/632ef0b1b801bc8dc590695674d3f1448c4bb66d/CLUSTER.md), then I believe we can have cluster V2 in a few years, say Valkey 10 or 11, maybe...

@PingXie Works for me. Is there a list of problems/requirements?

I don't see how you would perform a rolling upgrade to a cluster that meets these requirements. Is that acceptable?

We can deprecate anything at any time because it is just a comment or warning. Until we set a hard date on when it will be removed (breaking old systems),...

I like the general idea here. This could be a big help for applications that don't require clusters. Are there any dumb clients still in use? (Dumb meaning that they...

> @daniel-house Only cluster clients recognize -MOVED redirects. Far from all clients are cluster clients. I have heard of smart clients but never cluster clients. I am assuming that cluster=smart...

Hmmm, I find lots of references to "smart client" using Google, but none of them are on any Redis page. I also see terms like "cluster aware" and "caching". There...

I like using a totally new message such as REDIRECT. In the switchover there will be a period during which there is no server handling queries on the original master's...

> Reposting an earlier comment: > > > The answer was that single lines attached and multi-lines don't attach. It seems like clang supports it with BraceWrappingAfterControlStatementStyle MultiLine. I came...

I don't see a need for this change. The default value of `dir` is `./` at https://github.com/valkey-io/valkey/blob/8abeb79f52cbf02d16d546f48e16592173593132/valkey.conf#L517 and `NULL` at https://github.com/valkey-io/valkey/blob/8abeb79f52cbf02d16d546f48e16592173593132/src/config.c#L3280 so it can easily be handled via ~~~ cd...