damus icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
damus copied to clipboard

Feature Request: convert 🤘 to + for ActivityPub messages

Open Sjors opened this issue 1 year ago • 3 comments

The Mostr bridge converts + to Like, while everything else is converted to EmojiReact. The latter isn't supported by Mastodon, so it gets dropped on the floor.

It seems preferable to convert the default emoji for compatibility.

Perhaps to also disable custom emojis.

Downside is that some ActivityPub systems, not Mastodon, do support EmojiReact. Nostr clients can't tell the difference across the bridge (unless Mostr adds a tag to indicate this).

See also: https://gitlab.com/soapbox-pub/mostr/-/merge_requests/116

Sjors avatar Sep 15 '24 16:09 Sjors

Great suggestion @Sjors

I added this as a suggested best practice on nostrability repo

https://github.com/nostrability/nostrability/issues/96

alltheseas avatar Sep 15 '24 16:09 alltheseas

That said, it might be fine to allow more expressive emoji's as a reaction, for other nostr users to see. But the UI should make it clear that the author won't see it.

Sjors avatar Sep 15 '24 17:09 Sjors

But the UI should make it clear that the author won't see it.

Agree it's a design problem. Unsure of the best solution.

@robagreda @karnagebitcoin

alltheseas avatar Sep 15 '24 18:09 alltheseas