dail8859
Windows ARM Support
Description
Hi maintainers! First of all, thank you for this great project. Nowadays, Windows on ARM devices like the Surface Pro X are becoming increasingly popular. I would love to use this editor natively on these devices. However, the current build seems to target x86/x64 architectures only. I was wondering if there are any plans to support ARM architecture in the near future?
Describe the solution you'd like
No response
Describe alternatives you've considered
No response
Having ARM support would be desirable, but I have no experience or way to test/debug builds for ARM. If someone was willing to contribute the required changes to the code, project files, CI/CD, etc I'd be very willing to accept it. I wouldn't be able to offer too much help but would try where I could.
Hopefully GitHub runner supports Windows ARM soon: https://github.com/github/roadmap/issues/1098
This is great news! However, after checking the documentation, Windows ARM runners are not currently available for public repositories. That said, if someone could submit a PR to address architecture-specific issues, I can immediately build and test it on my Windows ARM device. Additionally, I'm willing to provide remote administrator access to a Windows ARM VM for anyone qualified to tackle this.
So I possibly(?) think I have some good news.
On my PC I was able to install the arm64 libraries for visual studio, and the arm64 libraries for Qt and was able to compile the code and get an executable pretty easily. I of course cannot run the application or verify anything is correct other than I get no errors while building. There's also no windeployqt for arm, so I'm not sure the best way to even begin to test this.
I could potentially zip up the equivalent arm dlls as the normal version has, but that would be a shot in the dark.
You can send the binaries here or to my email (available on my Github profile). I'll be able to test them. As a side note: Today I noticed that NotepadNext on Flathub already has an arm64 build. You might consider creating an ARM-architecture AppImage and uploading it to the releases section. If needed, I also have a Linux arm64 device available for testing it. (Of course, Github Actions' newly launched Linux arm runners could also be used for testing, though desktop environments would require manual installation.)
You can send the binaries here or to my email
Give me a few days to try to find some time and I'll package them up and find some way to send them to you.
You might consider creating an ARM-architecture AppImage and uploading it to the releases section
If someone updated the github actions and it is not hard to maintain, I'd be glad to accept it. I have no way to debug if any of it goes wrong. Fighting with github actions is never fun :)
@lingyicute Apologies for the delay.
This is a complete shot in the dark so no clue if this will even work.
Extract and run the exe.
Sorry, I’ve been busy with exams these past few days. I just got the chance to try it out now.
It seems we’re missing a DLL:
I also tried it with the x64 version of qt6printsupport.dll, but this attempt clearly failed. I got an architecture mismatch error (0xc000007b).
This is fantastic! I've experimented with it and the software works perfectly. The picture shows the basic tests I did, such as opening files, finding and replacing, changing fonts, and so on. The only thing that is a bit strange is that the arm version of the notepadnext toolbar shows a sort of UWP style. Is this a feature of the new version of qt?
the arm version of the notepadnext toolbar shows a sort of UWP style. Is this a feature of the new version of qt?
I'm honestly not sure.
At this point I guess this proves an ARM build is possible but there's still a few things to work through.
- I think ARM support is in Qt6.5 but would have to double check. Any Qt version beyond that breaks the single application instance support.
- Building the ARM version would have to be set up with github actions. I've already proven you do not need the ARM runners to do this. Would probably need to manually install the ARM libraries for MSVC somehow (no clue how to do that), and the ARM libraries of Qt.
- It looks like Qt for ARM doesn't support the
windeployqtcommand line tool, making it very difficult to automate deployment of a new build.