ImageGlass icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
ImageGlass copied to clipboard

A/B Image Compare

Open camjac251 opened this issue 6 years ago • 14 comments

Would it be possible to support side by side image comparison? I was unable to find another image browser that offers this certain functionality. XNView has something but it puts two images side by side and not really on top of each other with a slider. Arnold has a nice workflow for comparing in its renderview, you'd have snapshots on the bottom, right click one and set as A and right click another and set as B, then A would be on top of B with a slider in the center, left or right to show more A/B. Right now to compare I pressing the left and right arrow key but it only works if the file order is correct or if the images are in the same directory.

camjac251 avatar Oct 09 '19 09:10 camjac251

@camjac251 ImageGlass supports multiple instance, so you can open that image in a separated window, then set this window always on top.

image

d2phap avatar Oct 09 '19 09:10 d2phap

I was hoping to split the image down the center to compare one half of A.png (left side) to B.png (right side). I don't think the windows always on top works for this situation. This is my current way of comparing two images in ImageGlass https://youtu.be/whUwZ0QXHQk. With Windows, alt tabbing back and forth or moving my mouse between the window previews causes a split second of the desktop background or alt tab menu to appear. The green bar on the right was an error in the screen capture software.

camjac251 avatar Oct 09 '19 09:10 camjac251

Hi @camjac251 For side-by-side comparing, you can just move the windows?

image

d2phap avatar Oct 09 '19 09:10 d2phap

Oh I see what you mean. I find it difficult to compare images side by side when I'm looking at the pixels.

I was hoping for something like this https://imgsli.com/NzMzNg, with one image on top of the other and a slider to control the crop of the two.

camjac251 avatar Oct 09 '19 10:10 camjac251

I was hoping for something like this https://imgsli.com/NzMzNg

I see. It's difficult actually 😁. I will find how. Thanks

d2phap avatar Oct 09 '19 10:10 d2phap

If it's easier, would it be possible to toggle between the current and last opened image with a keybind? Like if you double click an image to open it in the viewer then drag an image over it to open that one and pressing a key switches back?

camjac251 avatar Oct 09 '19 10:10 camjac251

I wish there could be an option to "stack vertically or horitontally" similar to Xnview, because if you have more than 2 images open and you want to do a side by side comparison you cannot do that easily within Windows.

fabeit avatar Oct 29 '20 13:10 fabeit

I have not been able to find another program that offers this functionality. There are many javascript libraries for web usage of comparing images but nothing in a convenient desktop app.

Did you see the above @d2phap about the last opened image toggle? This could be really useful if A/B comparison is complex. I tried comparing 2 images side by side but when i go to the next image, I have to set everything up again because the position of the scroll resets to the center.

camjac251 avatar Jan 03 '21 21:01 camjac251

Concerning the side-by-side comparison with multiple windows open, it would be very helpful to be able to toggle locking their zoom/scroll navigations. By this I mean that when navigating in one window using the mouse and/or keyboard, all other windows would mimic the same zoom/scroll such that all (locked) windows of ImageGlass always show the same part of their respective image. Of course, this is meant for a setting where both images have the same dimensions (or at least aspect ratio).

P.S.: As a reference on how this could work, FastStone image viewer has this feature.

nmevenkamp avatar Apr 13 '21 05:04 nmevenkamp

Just wanted to chime in that this feature would be quite nice to have. Was searching for it and found this discussion. Maybe it could just share the size/scrolling information between all active windows. That would already work great.

some9000 avatar Nov 25 '21 08:11 some9000

I am surprised that this still isn't a feature as that'd be really nice and something I sorely miss not having

Razor54672 avatar Mar 09 '23 07:03 Razor54672

Any update on this? I think it would be an amazing feature to have. I would love to see this happen.

RideOfPablo avatar Sep 17 '23 14:09 RideOfPablo

Oh I see what you mean. I find it difficult to compare images side by side when I'm looking at the pixels.

I was hoping for something like this https://imgsli.com/NzMzNg, with one image on top of the other and a slider to control the crop of the two.

This is far superior way of comparing images than side by side. I compare images a lot and my workflow has always been creating new folder, putting 2 images inside it, opening them and quickly switching between them. It's tedious and doesn't work if the 2 images have different resolutions and I want to zoom in.

This feature would be invaluable for me.

kex0 avatar Feb 27 '24 16:02 kex0

get butterflyviewer https://github.com/olive-groves/butterfly_viewer In wndows, use ctrl to select two images, open butterflyviewer, drag both images to butterflyviewer. lol why cant this do that?

Digita1Menace avatar Aug 13 '24 15:08 Digita1Menace