crunchy-cli icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
crunchy-cli copied to clipboard

Sunsetting

Open bytedream opened this issue 11 months ago โ€ข 12 comments

This project will be discontinued. As of 14.03.2024, Crunchyroll removed support for non-DRM streams. This change effectively kills the project.

DRM (digital rights management) is a type of copy protection that many streaming providers use. The video is sent encrypted by Crunchyroll and the user's device then decrypts it. Only the provider of the DRM encrypted media (in this case Crunchyroll) is allowed to decrypt it. Therefore, I cannot continue operating this tool legally. It's sad to see that yet another service went this way, but I guess that's just the way business works. It won't stop pirating. It won't stop copyright infringement. It might even lead to more illegal activity if the only option left for people to get their personal copy is file sharing or using actual illegal tools.

Besides the DRM stuff, I had little motivation left to continue developing the project in general. From that point of view, the DRM changeover was the death blow. As a single person, it was sometimes exhausting to maintain the project. On the one hand, users frequently requested new features and reported bugs, which made the codebase bigger and more complex, and on the other hand, working with the Crunchyroll isn't really enjoyable, there are just so many edgecases to pay attention to. In addition, I began working on other things that also require my time and attention.

But besides all this, I would like to thank everyone who contributed code, those who submitted enhancement requests and bug reports, those who have simply used the tool silently and those who have supported me in other ways. Without this user base, this project might have been discontinued way earlier. It went from being just another side project to my biggest open-source project (so far), I gained much experience in the years developing it and met nice people along the way :)


Edit (for readers in the future): As stated in https://github.com/crunchy-labs/crunchy-cli/issues/362#issuecomment-2034838294, the project discontinuation was delayed, but as of 16.08.2024 said DRM-free endpoint also got deactivated (see #438 for more information). It seems this is really the end.

bytedream avatar Mar 25 '24 12:03 bytedream

RIP, was one of the best tools out there and I'll miss it. :cry:

kerkmann avatar Mar 25 '24 13:03 kerkmann

Sad...

Nannk avatar Mar 25 '24 13:03 Nannk

Another project dies to Digital Restrictions Managementยน Anyway, good job keeping this up for so long :pray:

port19x avatar Mar 25 '24 13:03 port19x

Thank you for all the hard work and peaking my interest in using Rust for home projects. This was an awesome thing you did. I hope we get to see more of your work in other ways ๐Ÿ’ช๐Ÿป

koo04 avatar Mar 25 '24 17:03 koo04

Oh no, this is really sad news :(

Thanks for all your effort on this tool, it was really nice to use. I hope you find new and better projects to work on :3

naipotato avatar Mar 26 '24 03:03 naipotato

It's a shame but I can understand it. I will miss your tool, it was simple and easy to use. It was also the only one that converted the chapter perfectly, even if the function only came recently.

I wish you all the best, lots of luck, success and fun with your next projects :)

dok1100 avatar Mar 26 '24 10:03 dok1100

Thanks for your work @bytedream!

3c7 avatar Mar 26 '24 18:03 3c7

Thank You Buddy!!

GTM009 avatar Mar 28 '24 09:03 GTM009

RIP I just chanced upon this last week

wheynelau avatar Mar 28 '24 15:03 wheynelau

Some other projects have remained up by asking user to provide their own keys. But understandable if you don't want to get into muddy waters with Sony. Take care

ballenvironment avatar Apr 02 '24 07:04 ballenvironment

Well there is one endpoint which still has DRM-free streams, I guess I still have a bit time until (finally) everything is DRM-only. I'll suspend my discontinuation, as my left motivation wants me to keep the tool working as long as something DRM-free is available (although it's a bit cringe as my farewell message was a bit emotional heh). I will lock the issue until this endpoint is striked by DRM too and finally everything is DRM-only.

bytedream avatar Apr 03 '24 14:04 bytedream