James Craig

> Published test report: https://aria-at.w3.org/reports/1504 This appears to load a nearly blank page.

Okay, it looks like the site has serious performance problems. Each page, including the test case, takes minutes to load, so this is not an exhaustive review. However, I did...

@richnoah wrote: > we have implemented some performance improvements this morning. If you would not mind please try to access the pages again. These problems are still preventing review. See...

@jscholes wrote: > We'd like to discuss with you the possibility of Apple accepting the test as-written. I thought the purpose of this test was to ensure that the control...

@jscholes wrote: > Make VoiceOver's toggle button rendering consistent with its treatment of similar elements. In the same browser, VoiceOver explicitly conveys the "not checked" and "off" states of checkboxes...

>> Make VoiceOver's rendering of toggle buttons consistent with their treatment in iOS Safari, where VoiceOver communicates both states. > This is a reasonable request that I will discuss with...

the discussion yesterday concluded that meta+click was reasonable for multi-select (a.k.a "add to or remove from previous selection") foregoing shift+click for now (a.k.a "add to previous selection including all contiguous...

Yes, I agree. We should move this to 1.0.

This was previously covered by `value` (usually 0/1, and occasionally 2 for "mixed"), but the editors discussion conceded the usefulness of keeping the more discoverable "checked" pattern. We'll look into...

It was called `AccessibleNode` and extended `Node` b/c UAs need this on both element and text nodes, too. Not attrs though. It might be possible to split AccessibleNode into separate...