code-charity
Incompatibility with Return YouTube Dislike
Bug Report:
-
Description: The Return YouTube Dislike extension (https://github.com/Anarios/return-youtube-dislike) shows the like and dislike count, and also their ratio in a bar, as seen below.
When I also install the Improve YouTube extension, the bar no longer indicates the ratio (the like and dislike count works, but the ratio bar does not):
-
Steps to reproduce this: (Might only happen with a certain feature of our's enabled?) Tested on the following video, but the issue is not linked to a specific video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S7znI_Kpzbs. Install both your extension and the Return YouTube Dislike extension to reproduce the bug.
-
Since when?: Was always like this.
-
Browser: Firefox 130.0
-
Are any errors shown in the Browser-Console?: (
F12-key, thenconsole-tab) Yes, there are. But i) errors appear even without this extension, ii) I cannot interpret what they mean. So I exported the log, with Improve YouTube enabled and disabled: without_improve_youtube.txt with_improve_youtube.txt -
Does the bug not happen when you log out of YouTube? Then please copy your experiment flags list twice (with & without the error to compare). Enter:
yt.config_.EXPERIMENT_FLAGSinto the Browser console on youtube (F12-Key - Or find it in the html source(ctrl+U) . Indifferent whether logged in or out. Here are the flags with Improve YouTube enabled and disabled: experiment_flags_without_improveYT.txt experiment_flags_with_improveYT.txt
GitHub's issue search (use the link or remove "is:issue is:open" from the search)
-
Expected preferred behavior: I would like both extensions work correctly.
-
ImprovedTube Version (Written in the Extension header & your Browser's store): 4.096
-
Tested as only active extension or in incognito mode?: Yes, same behaviour.
-
Your Settings (From the Extension's
⋮-Hamburger menu > Settings > Backup & reset > Export settings (You can remove any Blocklist, History Analyzer data - or paste the following in the Browser-Console and hit enter:(function({analyzer, blocklist, ...a}){return JSON.stringify(a)})(ImprovedTube.storage)): Here it is: settings.json -
YouTube-Document: (
F12copy the whole root element: <html> (alternative: CTRL+U) (https://github.com/code-charity/youtube/wiki/Contributing#Test ) Here is the page source: page_source.txt -
OS / Device:
Linux pop-os 6.9.3-76060903-generic #202405300957~1721174657~22.04~abb7c06 SMP PREEMPT_DYNAMIC Wed J x86_64 x86_64 x86_64 GNU/Linux
hi! @CsatiZoltan thank you for caring!
interesting if it depends on one of youtube's experiment flags too! :
#2251
Does the bug not happen when you log out of YouTube? Then please copy your experiment flags list twice (with & without the error to compare). Enter: yt.config_.EXPERIMENT_FLAGS into the Browser console on youtube (F12-Key - Or find it in the html source(ctrl+U) . Indifferent whether logged in or out. Here are the flags with Improve YouTube enabled and disabled: experiment_flags_without_improveYT.txt experiment_flags_with_improveYT.txt
i'm looking forward to add your experiment flags to our complete list! (Even if it doesn't relate to this issue #2570 as i see now. The list changes a bit only when logging out of Youtube. So your two are the same.)
@ImprovedTube Reading https://github.com/Anarios/return-youtube-dislike/issues/875: unfortunately, I cannot help as I have no web development experience. All I can do is filing as complete bug report as possible (and I think I filled in all the entries in the bug report template of this issue).