meshlab icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
meshlab copied to clipboard

[Usability] Make it possible to Undo

Open plouj opened this issue 5 years ago • 8 comments

What parts of Meshlab would need to be changed to support an undo history for non-destructive editing?

plouj avatar Oct 14 '18 00:10 plouj

Undo is an extremely important feature to add

SHMAUS-Carter avatar Dec 04 '20 21:12 SHMAUS-Carter

I am aware of that. It just requires a huge reorganization of the core of meshlab. We are working on this, but it will require time.

alemuntoni avatar Dec 07 '20 10:12 alemuntoni

any update? this is basically a deal breaker for almost everyone

alexander-macleod avatar Feb 19 '22 12:02 alexander-macleod

As I said, I am aware of this. Unfortunately, the whole core of meshlab and vcg has not been written thinking about this scenario. Since our resources are limited, making this feature available will require a lot of planning and development. At the moment, I can say that it won't be available anytime soon. Sorry.

alemuntoni avatar Feb 22 '22 09:02 alemuntoni

you have done some great work indeed however I think that building a state buffer into the application or underlying framework would be such a huge win. feels like a crazy oversight in terms of general usability for a popular, professional application not to have a simple "undo" option anywhere

alexander-macleod avatar May 02 '22 09:05 alexander-macleod

I appreciate the work you do keeping this project free and open source. However, I find Meshlab extremely frustrating to use without a tool as critical as the undo button. One accidental click means I have to restart from scratch. This pain is amplified since there is no form of auto-save either. I would love to see the development team prioritize this feature.

TheLastMillennial avatar Oct 15 '22 00:10 TheLastMillennial

thanks to the meshlab team for all the work on this great piece of software.

any progress on the undo feature?

kzhang2 avatar Jan 21 '24 22:01 kzhang2

+1 on this

danielkyne-ox avatar Apr 06 '24 12:04 danielkyne-ox