cms-sw
Add Kalos heterogenous CLUE library as an external to CMSSW
Given a coming PR to CMSSW to enable the heterogeneous clustering using CLUE in HGCal CE-E detector at HLT for Phase2, see the evolving development branch here, I would like to add the Kalos library, that contains the Alpaka version of CLUE, as an external to CMSSW. It is a header-only library. The source code is available at this link.
@felicepantaleo @fwyzard @SohamBhattacharya @smuzaffar
A new Issue was created by @rovere.
@makortel, @sextonkennedy, @smuzaffar, @rappoccio, @antoniovilela, @Dr15Jones can you please review it and eventually sign/assign? Thanks.
cms-bot commands are listed here
thanks @rovere .
the requirements listed in the repo readme are quite strict and obsolete:
The pre-requisite dependencies are >=gcc7, <=gcc8.3, Boost, TBB. Fork this repo if developers. If CUDA/nvcc are found on the machine, the compilation is performed automatically also for the GPU case. The path to the nvcc compiler will be automatically taken from the machine. In this case, >=cuda10 and <=nvcc11.2 are also required.
Did you check that you can build it and run with a recent CMSSW environment?
thanks @rovere .
the requirements listed in the repo readme are quite strict and obsolete:
The pre-requisite dependencies are >=gcc7, <=gcc8.3, Boost, TBB. Fork this repo if developers. If CUDA/nvcc are found on the machine, the compilation is performed automatically also for the GPU case. The path to the nvcc compiler will be automatically taken from the machine. In this case, >=cuda10 and <=nvcc11.2 are also required.
Did you check that you can build it and run with a recent CMSSW environment?
@felicepantaleo everything is running fine in the latest CMSSW_14_1_X IB.
@smuzaffar those requirements, as @felicepantaleo said, are rather old and referring to slc7 ages. I tested the library in our more recent environment and it works fine. I will work on the requirements and update them to more recent standards, assuming the CI machinery at CERN allows me to do so.
New categories assigned: core,heterogeneous,hlt,reconstruction,upgrade
@Dr15Jones,@Martin-Grunewald,@mmusich,@fwyzard,@jfernan2,@makortel,@makortel,@mandrenguyen,@smuzaffar,@srimanob,@subirsarkar you have been requested to review this Pull request/Issue and eventually sign? Thanks
I'd like to understand better the long-term plan. Is the external setup intended as a temporary or long-term solution? Does the Kalos library have any CMS-specifics, or is it fully generic?
(in a way this situation reminds me of the initial mkFit integration)
Ciao @makortel, the plan would be to have a standalone library that CMS could use in CMSSW and other experiments elsewhere. The library has been "packaged and included" under the key4hep umbrella see here.
The final goal would be to have a unique external library that could be plugged into several places.
On a side note, extracting the "kernels" needed by CMSSW/HGCAL from Kalos would be a "relatively simple" exercise if that solution is preferred.
