planet-php icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
planet-php copied to clipboard

Report content feature

Open rdohms opened this issue 10 years ago • 22 comments

There have been many discussions in the PHP community about "curating" our sources. Not all sources follow new paradigms and have great content, this is where PHP The Right Way came from, an attempt to curate a list of good information to fight some of the articles from the PHP4 era and similar sources.

In order to be able to judge if the sources in PlanetPHP ate up to the standards we all come to expect, it would be nice to implement a "report" button. Something that allows the users to express their opinion about a source, allowing the admins to make decisions on which sources should be dropped or not.

I would suggest some discussion to determine a transparent criteria and the implementation of the button with a flag system that allows admins to manage the results.

I'm willing to put in the work to solve this if we can all agree on what this should look/work like.

rdohms avatar Feb 03 '15 11:02 rdohms

+1 to this. This also could be useful when someone's PHP blog veers off into non-PHP land (or turns into more of a marketing pitch).

enygma avatar Feb 03 '15 12:02 enygma

+1

Stelian avatar Feb 03 '15 12:02 Stelian

Since there is currently no "admin" console, I would maybe suggest this be an open and transparent leaderboard anyone can view, and the admin continue managing the blog list as they do, but with this as information.

rdohms avatar Feb 03 '15 13:02 rdohms

+1 Yes, we need this.

matthiasnoback avatar Mar 09 '15 13:03 matthiasnoback

+1 YES

jeroenvdgulik avatar Mar 09 '15 13:03 jeroenvdgulik

+1

rianorie avatar Mar 09 '15 13:03 rianorie

:+1:

mitchellvanw avatar Mar 09 '15 13:03 mitchellvanw

:+1:

ramsey avatar Mar 09 '15 13:03 ramsey

:+1:

frankdejonge avatar Mar 09 '15 13:03 frankdejonge

+1

dstockto avatar Mar 09 '15 13:03 dstockto

+1

Brunty avatar Mar 09 '15 13:03 Brunty

+1 for the ideea.

rendler-denis avatar Mar 09 '15 13:03 rendler-denis

+1

nurikabe avatar Mar 09 '15 13:03 nurikabe

+1

fhjbalfoort avatar Mar 09 '15 13:03 fhjbalfoort

:+1:

erickpatrick avatar Mar 09 '15 13:03 erickpatrick

+1

jaspernbrouwer avatar Mar 09 '15 14:03 jaspernbrouwer

+1

helderjs avatar Mar 09 '15 14:03 helderjs

+1

derickr avatar Mar 09 '15 15:03 derickr

Oh, come on. You know how this works. Send pull requests! ;)

chregu avatar Mar 09 '15 15:03 chregu

@chregu can you read through and give me some feedback on the implementation details, i'll set some time aside to code it.

My personal opinion would be:

  • implement report button
  • public page that shows filed reports anonymized
  • admins then use the current means (DB) for removing offenders

How does this sound to you and the Planet Team? No need to add authenticated pages since that concept does not yet exist in the app, but it does require buy-in from admins to check page and execute on feedback.

rdohms avatar Mar 09 '15 15:03 rdohms

+1 :D

michellesanver avatar Mar 09 '15 17:03 michellesanver

:+1: so many times!!!!

WyriHaximus avatar Mar 09 '15 19:03 WyriHaximus