marble icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
marble copied to clipboard

Without Firebase

Open gelinger777 opened this issue 1 year ago • 6 comments

Any plans to have fully independent database instead of firebase? I liked your product , but it does not appeal to me to be used , just because of it.

gelinger777 avatar Nov 28 '24 01:11 gelinger777

Hi @gelinger777 , Thanks for your post. We have this on our radar, as you are not the first one to ask. May I ask what your favorite alternatives would be, and what features they should expose ?

Pascal-Delange avatar Nov 28 '24 12:11 Pascal-Delange

@Pascal-Delange hi, as you deal mostly with time series data and the speed is crutially important i would choose InfluxDB 3.0 as a basis for storing and analyising data . OSS version of v3 which is 45x faster is coming very soon, but available for development and cloud . As they have OSS Free Model , your customers will not need to pay extra for using it. Plus it has tons of ingestion features , speed etc. I would be loving to use your product in our company in that case. Firebase makes it quite scary to be honest.

gelinger777 avatar Nov 29 '24 17:11 gelinger777

I think there is a misunderstanding. At Marble, we only use Firebase for Authentication (not storage). By reading your issue, we missed the "database" part (since we do have internal discussion for making the product agnostic or at least independant from Firebase auth).

tl;dr: we do not rely on Firebase for storage

balzdur avatar Dec 02 '24 09:12 balzdur

Hi Folks!

An alternatve is to implement Oauth 2.0, so we can use any service avail in market, including Auth0, Keycloack ando so on....

Wosniak avatar Jan 03 '25 13:01 Wosniak

Yeah i support @Wosniak 's offer.

gelinger777 avatar Jan 06 '25 15:01 gelinger777

I also want to implement login and email sending via SMTP configuration, without using Firebase. (It doesn’t matter whether the SMTP settings are managed via env, config, or GUI.) Additionally, I hope that MFA features such as email OTP authentication or Google OTP authentication can be enabled from the GUI. If this is possible, I believe Marble could be used even in closed environments without external network access.

Please consider this request!

hcjang0313 avatar May 09 '25 13:05 hcjang0313

Hi, We are finally getting close to this. Marble (with license) will be compatible with any IDP provided supporting OIDC for authentication, in the next month or two.

Pascal-Delange avatar Oct 06 '25 15:10 Pascal-Delange

Hi, It's available now, so I'm closing the issue ! See the doc

Pascal-Delange avatar Nov 19 '25 12:11 Pascal-Delange