packages icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
packages copied to clipboard

[Maintenance] Drop KF5/Qt5 packages. Migrate to KF6/Qt6.

Open xiota opened this issue 1 year ago • 17 comments

Arch switched to KF6/Qt6 a couple months ago. Manjaro switched recently. Qt5 is long past end of life.

This issue serves as advance notice. Changes will occur over the next few ~~months~~ [years], or longer. Probably won't be complete until [long] after the v4-build transition.

  • Planning to switch to KF6/Qt6 packages when possible.
  • Planning to drop KF5/Qt5 packages eventually.
    • Will avoid adding any new KF5/Qt5 packages.
    • Will keep working KF5/Qt5 packages for now.
      • Will drop KF5/Qt6 packages that break, rather than try to fix via interfere or other means.

Exceptions:

  • Maintainer packages with no Qt6 alternative. These will be kept working for as long as possible.
  • Packages that build Qt5 packages alongside versions for other toolkits. Attempts to fix will be made. However, the Qt5 component may be disabled if fixing is deemed pointless or hopeless.

xiota avatar May 18 '24 02:05 xiota

octopi is now on this list due to the dependency qt-sudo. Edit: no longer an issue

Technetium1 avatar May 19 '24 18:05 Technetium1

This is a debacle 👀 though the AUR page provides this PKGBUILD: https://github.com/yochananmarqos/pkgbuilds/blob/master/qt-sudo/PKGBUILD

dr460nf1r3 avatar May 19 '24 19:05 dr460nf1r3

There's no rush to drop packages. There's still time for maintainers to update.

The maintainer of octopi has been working on it.

qt5-webkit is ultimately doomed though. Will have to see which dependents can be updated to Qt6.

  • csxcad-git # doesn't use Qt
  • ~~goldendict-git~~ # dropping; use goldendict-webengine-pr-git
  • ~~olivia-git~~ # dropping
  • ~~smtube~~ # dropping
  • ~~wkhtmltopdf~~ # dropping

xiota avatar May 20 '24 00:05 xiota

octopi is now on this list due to the dependency qt-sudo.

Got updated: https://aur.archlinux.org/cgit/aur.git/commit/?h=qt-sudo&id=3da895e7725c39cc46c6352ff886776131caf68a

dr460nf1r3 avatar May 20 '24 15:05 dr460nf1r3

Interfere applied to Octopi thanks @dr460nf1r3 🎉 https://github.com/chaotic-aur/interfere/commit/ce4d68b1e00c092abe390bd9e2d3780c3310bd79

Technetium1 avatar May 20 '24 15:05 Technetium1

  • csxcad-git

This one is specially important since we use openems-git for some classes, which depends on csxcad-git.

thotypous avatar May 20 '24 19:05 thotypous

openems-git and csxcad-git don't use Qt/webkit. Switched them to custom pkgbuilds via interfere.

Related qcsxcad-git and appcsxcad-git do use Qt.

xiota avatar May 21 '24 01:05 xiota

Dropping qt5-webkit because it looks too complicated to fix. It was deprecated years ago, and the project keeping it alive quit ~2020.

xiota avatar May 22 '24 04:05 xiota

Asked about Qt6 migration of megasync https://github.com/meganz/MEGAsync/issues/954#issuecomment-2137822766

Technetium1 avatar May 29 '24 16:05 Technetium1

Is there something we can do about rstudio-desktop? It's actually pretty important for the UFSCar arch image

thotypous avatar May 30 '24 03:05 thotypous

ventoy-bin is now on this list. I've created an issue because I uncovered much larger underlying problems with their CI: https://github.com/ventoy/Ventoy/issues/2858

Technetium1 avatar May 30 '24 03:05 Technetium1

@thotypous The maintainer of rstudio-desktop has found a workaround for the issues. I'll add it back under the Paulo section.

xiota avatar May 30 '24 03:05 xiota

ksmoothdock is on chopping block. Leaving it for now.

xiota avatar Jun 06 '24 01:06 xiota

octopi-git is effectively unmaintained.

xiota avatar Jul 04 '24 05:07 xiota

ms-office-online depends on orphaned jade-application-kit, which depends on pyside2/Qt5.

xiota avatar Jul 04 '24 06:07 xiota

pls dont drop qt5 packages, they are my favorite

SteavenGamerYT avatar Jul 14 '24 21:07 SteavenGamerYT

@SteavenGamerYT Programs and packages that are not updated to Qt6 are basically unmaintained. There has not been a systematic purge of Qt5 packages. Most packages that have been dropped so far had other problems, like failure on rebuild.

xiota avatar Jul 16 '24 04:07 xiota