Release Candidate Comments (New Contributors Closing Issues)

[klumb]

This issue was created to collect comments about the upcoming metrics release.

This thread is for comments about New Contributors Closing Issues

GitHub location: https://github.com/chaoss/wg-evolution/blob/master/metrics/New_Contributor_Closing_Issues.md

See all release candidates of metrics are at: https://chaoss.community/metrics-202001/

[foundjem]

I have this minor concern other wise LGTM

During implementation should we consider both types of contributors “especially for contributors who are not also committers?”

Signed-off-by: Foundjem [email protected]

[klumb]

@foundjem, what do you mean by "both types of contributors"?

[bproffitt]

Wondering if the title for this is correct. These are not new contributors, so much as contributors closing issues for the first time on a given project.

Also this metric feels incomplete. Are there no tool implementations?

[jgbarah]

I agree with you, @bproffitt. The idea was to keep a general name "New Contributors", and then a "category name" (Closing Issues), which would read as "new contributors in closing issues" or more clearly "persons closing issues for the first time". I don't know if it is better to keep all kinds of "new contributors" with a common name, or it is better to write it in the form which is easier to understand.

[klumb]

It would be nice to have common naming conventions for the metrics but I don't think we have been able to develop a usable structure so I would agree with @jgbarah and @bproffitt we should probably go with what is easiest to understand.

[klumb]

Is this metric ready for release?

[ccarterlandis]

@tommens has a PR still open for this metric (#297), do we want to wait just a little longer in case others have suggestions for the name, or go ahead and merge?

[GeorgLink]

PR was merged and is part of the release. Closing issue to get everything ready for release.

[ElizabethN]

This metric could use a refresh. It basically reads well, but there may be more context we want to give for getting this data. We don't mention Augur or GrimoireLab at all.

[ElizabethN]

Doing a little repo cleanup today and I'm going to close this, as we are currently updating all metrics to a new metric template, including a refresh.