Fail to take over map from c:geo

[Lineflyer]

Using our current market release 2020.12.03 and WhereYouGo nightly 2021.01.05-NB I am able to take over the c:geo used offline map into WhereYouGo (given it uses Mapsforge v3 format)

However using our current c:geo nightlies it fails to take over the map with: "Fehler beim Festlegen der Kartendatei (not a file: /storage/emulated/0/offlinemaps)"

@moving-bits @eddiemuc @fm-sys Wasn' there a change of how we store the used offline map file / folder recently between 2020.12.03 and today? It seems this makes the takeover in WhereYouGo fail.

[eddiemuc]

Yes, as of now only the Offline Map Directory is transferred to WhereYouGo, not the currently selectred file.

This could be fixed. for now. However, latest with the merge of SAF WhereYouGo can no longer use this information from c:geo since

• it will then be an Uri (Update: it will also not be a file Uri but a content Uri)
• it will be calculated "on-the-fly" out of base uri and map name
• it will not be reachable by WhereYouGo unless WhereYouGo implements scoped storage and the user allows access to same dir

This was discussed in cgeo/cgeo#8457 around 25 Nov 2020 and is an unavoidable regression. We have to find a new strategy for WhereYouGo how to deal with offline maps I am afraid, the current hack solution will no longer work.

[Lineflyer]

This was discussed in #8457 around 25 Nov 2020 and is an unavoidable regression. We have to find a new strategy for WhereYouGo how to deal with offline maps I am afraid, the current hack solution will no longer work.

Understand....now it gets a bit complicated: In fact the user who reported #249 was able to overcome it with the workaround to just get the map file location from c:geo. However once we remove that function (and we should do so) we need to fix #249 or even better upgrade the mapsforge library for WhereYouGo.

[SchoolGuy]

As said in the original issue for mapsforge v4/v5 support... When the settings are done I will implement the new map formats.

[Lineflyer]

@SchoolGuy Thanks for working on it! Highly appreciated.

I recently had a user on support wanting to contribute to WhereYouGo. I directed him to the repository..so some help might be on the way.

[eddiemuc]

It should be fairly simple to replace the current map file selection dialog in whereyougo with an intent call to action-open-document. If mapsforge 0.3 already supports opening map files via inputstream then this can be done even before map lib upgrade .

[moving-bits]

For the time being PR #420 removes the menu entry "acquire map from c:geo", as it currently does not make sense any longer. Functionality can be reactivated when WhereYouGo starts supporting both SAF and Mapsforge v5 maps.