CIPs icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
CIPs copied to clipboard

Published 20 hours ago • verified publisher icon ceramicnetwork

Discussion: Tile Doctype

Open oed opened this issue 4 years ago • 5 comments

Discussion for CIP-8.

oed avatar Jul 23 '20 11:07 oed

Looks great! Questions/suggestions:

  • The unique property should include a random number that ensures that there is no other document that is exactly the same. Do we need to restrict it to numbers only?
  • Should we consider introducing a property next with embedded content and metadata instead of having separate properties nextContent and nextMetadata?

simonovic86 avatar Jul 23 '20 12:07 simonovic86

A few questions/comments/thoughts:

  • Should tile be capitalized or no? I think it can be capitalized everywhere except when written as code (tile) and referenced by name in the header of a new document.
  • This isn't a Core CIP, it's just an RFC since specific doctypes are not part of the core protocol.
  • Same as Janko re: content and metadata.

michaelsena avatar Jul 23 '20 13:07 michaelsena

Updated to reflect your comments @simonovic86. Also updated https://github.com/ceramicnetwork/CIP/issues/37

Thanks for making all of those edits @michaelsena 🙏

oed avatar Jul 23 '20 16:07 oed

@oed Should the implementations section link directly to the ceramic-doctype-tile package in the js-ceramic repo?

michaelsena avatar Jul 23 '20 16:07 michaelsena

Good point @michaelsena I'm hesitant to link that though since we talked about changing the name of the package so the link might break. Adding some additional context instead.

oed avatar Jul 24 '20 06:07 oed