Benjamin W. Bohl comments

Results 395 comments of


                                            Benjamin W. Bohl

Change macro name of data.OTHERSTAFF

So the question concerning your proposed changes would be: what are ”adjacent layers”?

Missing documentation on linking attributes

`@data`

make stem.vis part of att.extSym and att.visibility

@martha-thomae and @annplaksin could you please add your reviews ;-)

schema: create agent in MEI shared

> In my opinion, `` isn't needed. Its intended function can be encoded using ``. `` has the added benefit of being able to associate multiple roles with a name...

adapt instrDef to staffDef

Like the harmonisation, nevertheless dislike that you had to reference all those other classes just to change one of them… Seems to me that maybe we should rethink the attribute...

Suggestion: `@tgrp` for horizontal shifting and alignment of notes in polyphony

would this just introduce `@tgrp` or also remove `@ho`?

add class "att.coordinated" to element <clip>

I agree with @ahankinson that some info on potential use cases would help evaluate this idea. Adding `att.coordinated` to `` would require rephrasing the element's description because it is defined...

Incompleteness of note head encoding

concerning 1. I think we should try to rephrase the description of `@head.shape` removing the implicit assumptions. made by "override" "normally" and "duration" words. Why not just say something like:...

Incompleteness of note head encoding

2021-10-28 ODD meeting: * maybe some kind of notation style definition in the header could help * documentation and best practice examples will be essential to documenting this

Allow nested zones

I second this deviation from the TEI model. And also think that keeping the facsimile tree a flat (two-dimensional) space is adequate and more clear for describing a two-dimensional space....