audapolis icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
audapolis copied to clipboard

Feature request: FLAC support

Open Susticle opened this issue 2 years ago • 3 comments

Thank you very much for this project.

Currently when using audapolis, I often have to convert audio from FLAC format to one understood by audapolis.

It would be great if audapolis would be able to handle this file type directly. :-)

Susticle avatar Sep 08 '22 07:09 Susticle

Quick question: Which do you want:

  1. Import FLACs which then get converted into a format audapolis supports automatically, probably a lossy process
  2. Directly support FLACs in audapolis, not converting them into another format automatically, but instead working directly on the FLACs file, losing as little quality as possible?

pajowu avatar Sep 13 '22 22:09 pajowu

My use case is currently transcription only so a bit of audio loss wouldn't hurt me.

I don't know how audapolis handles other formats internally, though. I think I saw something like "converted to m4a"? For me it wouldn't be a problem if audapolis would handle FLAC the same way.

Hope my answers help. Thank you very much!

Susticle avatar Sep 14 '22 06:09 Susticle

For other formats, we currently try a lossless conversion to mp4, as this container formats works better. If this fails, we currently show a warning about degraded performance to the user and then try to use the original file format.

I think we could replace this fallback with the option to do a (slow and lossy) conversion to mp4.

pajowu avatar Sep 29 '22 13:09 pajowu