GoMap icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
GoMap copied to clipboard

Deleting of a member(ship) should be possible

Open DerKarlos opened this issue 4 years ago • 5 comments

User Story

I could not solve a fixme: a tourist sign was placed twice in OSM. And both have been part of a relation. I could view the relation and its members but not delete a member

As [stakeholder], I want [action], so that [benefit]
Deleting of a member(ship) should be possible

Unhappy Cases

Editing relations may be critical, especially for beginners. So an extra warning may pop up

DerKarlos avatar May 30 '20 09:05 DerKarlos

Rather than allow general editing of relations I'd prefer to have a whitelist of allowed operations that we can ensure won't be destructive. Can you be more specific about what type of relation it was and what type of member?

bryceco avatar May 31 '20 04:05 bryceco

In this case it was an KeepRight/fixit "exact position" at a info sign. The info was one of a line, connected by a relation, no way included. But the sign was twice in the relation (may be there had been two once) To delete one of them could be on the whitelist, i assume.

DerKarlos avatar May 31 '20 06:05 DerKarlos

I see, so the same node appeared twice in the relation, not that there were two nodes with identical information?

On May 30, 2020, at 11:37 PM, Karl-Josef Adler [email protected] wrote:

 In this case it was an KeepRight/fixit "exact position" at a info sign. The info was one of a line, connected by a relation, way included. But the sign was twice in the relation (may be there had been two once) To delete one of them could be on the whitelist, i assume.

— You are receiving this because you commented. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub, or unsubscribe.

bryceco avatar May 31 '20 08:05 bryceco

No, it realy had been two notes, with slicely different tagging

DerKarlos avatar May 31 '20 08:05 DerKarlos

Progress?

TheAdventurer64 avatar Sep 12 '20 04:09 TheAdventurer64