cosore icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
cosore copied to clipboard

Research existing standards and practices

Open bpbond opened this issue 5 years ago • 7 comments

The first of our ESS-DIVE goals:

Research existing standards and practices in use at relevant agencies both within the US and Internationally. Included in this research will be projects within the DOE ESS community

bpbond avatar Jan 14 '20 11:01 bpbond

Sources off the top of my head:

Soil chamber fluxes

  • The SRDB
  • Hibbard (if available?), and older compendia of annual fluxes
  • Powell Center group - I think Danielle put this on our Google Sheet
  • Avni's work

Gas fluxes more generally

  • SIDb - https://www.earth-syst-sci-data.net/12/61/2020/
  • Ameriflux and FLUXNET

bpbond avatar Jan 14 '20 12:01 bpbond

Link back to January progress doc: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1NIkr2oBpze5YnNg6EG87CHbOisjMaHleXmMggOJtC_8/edit?ts=5e18fe4c

bpbond avatar Jan 14 '20 12:01 bpbond

Our standards are comprised of

  • Structure
  • How it's put together (traceability, reproducibility)
  • Usability (for end users)

If we start with a survey, hopefully via google forms, we can ask them to assess (not important, ... very important) above categories, not individual fields.

bpbond avatar Jan 21 '20 15:01 bpbond

Structure

  • How important is it to record specific variables (e.g. curve fit, R2)?
  • Ancillary measurements: how important is it to record these?
  • COSORE providing a "level 2" homogenized dataset with climate data, soils data, etc. already merged in?
  • Current bare-minimum is (flux, Timestamp end, begin, port # , where, how, by whom)... (more requirements == fewer data) do you think these should change?

Traceability/reproducibility

  • How important is it that a flux value in cosore is traceably back to the original raw file?

Useability

stephpenn1 avatar Jan 21 '20 16:01 stephpenn1

See my edits in the survey; we can discuss.

bpbond avatar Jan 27 '20 00:01 bpbond

Reminder from call 2020-03-26: Deb suggests engaging with NGEE folks about COSORE. We should say we've done that by next month.

bpbond avatar Mar 26 '20 18:03 bpbond

...include them on survey expansion, for example.

bpbond avatar Mar 26 '20 18:03 bpbond