Bottles
Bottles copied to clipboard
bottlesdevs
[BUG] Cannot manipulate the LDT on Flatpak
When trying to run some random old program with Bottles under Flatpak, the following error pops up:
modify_ldt: Operation not permitted
wine: Unhandled page fault on read access to 000002F8 at address 7E267241 (thread 010c), starting debugger...
Can't attact process 0104: error 5
The culprit might be Flatpak not allowing manipulation of LDT entries, and seems to align with a ticket over at Lutris: https://github.com/flathub/net.lutris.Lutris/issues/85
I've also run into this problem before. Have you considered implementing the temporary patch/workaround that the Lutris team had:
"Hello! how did you patch out the ban? I am trying to set League on PS4 gentoo but I get this error. Can you please tell?
Removing these lines should do: https://github.com/flatpak/flatpak/blob/6f86a8ff423a2e7a8e1db70c69612f3fa49ae9d4/common/flatpak-run.c#L2899-L2901"
Considering this issue has been open since December 2019 (2 years ago) you may be waiting a while for news from the Flatpak front.
Are you sure Lutris is patching Flatpak? It sounds weird :D
That's a good point. Looks like it used to lead to this link https://flathub.org/apps/details/net.lutris.Lutris but is no longer available.
"Lutris on Flatpak Lutris is an Open Source gaming platform for Linux. It installs and launches games so you can start playing without the hassle of setting up your games. This repository allows installing Lutris through Flatpak."
Either way, it would be appreciated if you could test or implement that temporary patch/workaround until Flatpak does whatever they need to do.
Ya but such patch is for flatpak (the “whole flatpak project”) not just our Bottles flatpak. This mean the users should replace their flatpak support with our one 😅
Oh, did this get fixed already? Why did the ticket get closed?
Just missclicked 😅
Still waiting for news on Flatpak side.
Hello mirkobrombin, first, thank you for all the work to make wine so easy to use by providing Bottles. I just wondering if you have been able to get some news from Flatpak side on this issue ? Availability to allow withelisting temporary LDT when necessary or other workaround ? Or this issue/request on Flatpak seems to be doomed and will stay that way ?
Thanks for your feedback!
Good news! https://github.com/flatpak/flatpak/pull/5082 fixes this issue by allowing modify_ldt within Flatpak. This should be available in the next release, but unfortunately I do not know when this will ever happen. I'm closing this issue since it's outside of our control anyway.
