unit test index_rtree_exceptions_rst fails

[barendgehrels]

It is currently the only failing test. Report:

99% tests passed, 1 tests failed out of 388

Total Test time (real) = 207.51 sec

The following tests FAILED:
	370 - boost_geometry_index_rtree_exceptions_rst (Failed)

388/388 Test 370: boost_geometry_index_rtree_exceptions_rst ...................***Failed    7.75 sec

Details:

$ ./index/test/rtree/exceptions/boost_geometry_index_rtree_exceptions_rst
Running 1 test case...
.../boost/libs/geometry/index/test/rtree/exceptions/test_exceptions.hpp:53: error: in "test_main_caller( argc_ argv )": check bgi::detail::rtree::utilities::are_counts_ok(tree, false) has failed
.../boost/libs/geometry/index/test/rtree/exceptions/test_exceptions.hpp:53: error: in "test_main_caller( argc_ argv )": check bgi::detail::rtree::utilities::are_counts_ok(tree, false) has failed
.../boost/libs/geometry/index/test/rtree/exceptions/test_exceptions.hpp:53: error: in "test_main_caller( argc_ argv )": check bgi::detail::rtree::utilities::are_counts_ok(tree, false) has failed
.../boost/libs/geometry/index/test/rtree/exceptions/test_exceptions.hpp:53: error: in "test_main_caller( argc_ argv )": check bgi::detail::rtree::utilities::are_counts_ok(tree, false) has failed
.../boost/libs/geometry/index/test/rtree/exceptions/test_exceptions.hpp:53: error: in "test_main_caller( argc_ argv )": check bgi::detail::rtree::utilities::are_counts_ok(tree, false) has failed
.../boost/libs/geometry/index/test/rtree/exceptions/test_exceptions.hpp:53: error: in "test_main_caller( argc_ argv )": check bgi::detail::rtree::utilities::are_counts_ok(tree, false) has failed
.../boost/libs/geometry/index/test/rtree/exceptions/test_exceptions.hpp:53: error: in "test_main_caller( argc_ argv )": check bgi::detail::rtree::utilities::are_counts_ok(tree, false) has failed

*** 7 failures are detected in the test module "Test Program"

[awulkiew]

I'll look at it. Any idea what caused it? https://github.com/boostorg/geometry/pull/1391, https://github.com/boostorg/geometry/pull/1392 or something else?

[awulkiew]

Where does it fail? It seems to be fine: https://www.boost.org/development/tests/develop/developer/geometry-index.html It's not tested on CircleCI. Are you running it locally or am I missing something?

[barendgehrels]

I'm running it locally... apart from are_counts_ok(tree, false) I don't have more info (yet)

[barendgehrels]

It's the only test failing. If it is only locally I'm also fine excluding it from cmake. But it's still weird.

[barendgehrels]

If I change the code from

BOOST_CHECK(bgi::detail::rtree::utilities::are_counts_ok(tree, false));

into:

BOOST_CHECK_MESSAGE(bgi::detail::rtree::utilities::are_counts_ok(tree, false),
            "are_counts_ok failed"
            << " at i = " << i
            << " with max_calls = " << throwing_value::get_max_calls_ref());

I get the next output:

Running 1 test case...
.../boost/libs/geometry/index/test/rtree/exceptions/test_exceptions.hpp:56: error: in "test_main_caller( argc_ argv )": are_counts_ok failed at i = 34 with max_calls = 34
.../boost/libs/geometry/index/test/rtree/exceptions/test_exceptions.hpp:56: error: in "test_main_caller( argc_ argv )": are_counts_ok failed at i = 36 with max_calls = 36
.../boost/libs/geometry/index/test/rtree/exceptions/test_exceptions.hpp:56: error: in "test_main_caller( argc_ argv )": are_counts_ok failed at i = 38 with max_calls = 38
.../boost/libs/geometry/index/test/rtree/exceptions/test_exceptions.hpp:56: error: in "test_main_caller( argc_ argv )": are_counts_ok failed at i = 40 with max_calls = 40
.../boost/libs/geometry/index/test/rtree/exceptions/test_exceptions.hpp:56: error: in "test_main_caller( argc_ argv )": are_counts_ok failed at i = 42 with max_calls = 42
.../boost/libs/geometry/index/test/rtree/exceptions/test_exceptions.hpp:56: error: in "test_main_caller( argc_ argv )": are_counts_ok failed at i = 44 with max_calls = 44
.../boost/libs/geometry/index/test/rtree/exceptions/test_exceptions.hpp:56: error: in "test_main_caller( argc_ argv )": are_counts_ok failed at i = 46 with max_calls = 46

*** 7 failures are detected in the test module "Test Program"

If I comment the BOOST_CHECK_THROW line, the test passes.

I don't understand the test, and I don't understand the failure, so it's up to you...

[awulkiew]

Sure, no problem, thanks for the details. I'd like to try to reproduce it. What's the OS and compiler?

[awulkiew]

I'd probably also need cmake options.

[barendgehrels]

Sure, no problem, thanks for the details. I'd like to try to reproduce it. What's the OS and compiler?

I've:

Apple clang version 15.0.0 (clang-1500.1.0.2.5)
Target: arm64-apple-darwin23.6.0

Darwin MAC-CJ6XM46W09 23.6.0 Darwin Kernel Version 23.6.0: Thu Mar  6 21:58:56 PST 2025; root:xnu-10063.141.1.704.6~1/RELEASE_ARM64_T6020 arm64

For clang I don't set extra options.