atproto icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
atproto copied to clipboard

Can't post videos or gifs

Open TodePond opened this issue 1 year ago • 1 comments

Is your feature request related to a problem? Please describe.

I'm sad when I can't post work-in-progress clips of things I'm working on. I'm stuck with posting them on twitter or mastodon instead.

eg: https://twitter.com/TodePond/status/1547200031161257986 eg: https://elk.zone/universeodon.com/@TodePond/110475890223132158

Describe the solution you'd like

I would like to be able to upload gifs and videos when I post (not just images).

Describe alternatives you've considered

I've also tried linking to gifs+videos, so that they embed within the feed - but this isn't supported yet.

Additional context

There was an old issue about this (#519) , which was closed. So I thought I would write it out fully using the new issue templates - so that it can be properly considered.

TodePond avatar Jun 03 '23 06:06 TodePond

i wonder if it would be possible to do video embeds in-app, like how vxtwitter displays video directly in telegram but not discord.

ianklatzco avatar Jun 03 '23 07:06 ianklatzco

I've been hoping for external embeds at the very least: YouTube, Imgur, SoundCloud, Sketchfab, etc. If I could add a link as a card, and then have that card load the embedded player in the post itself, that would really help open things up.

HeyItsLollie avatar Aug 19 '23 01:08 HeyItsLollie

Head on over to https://github.com/bluesky-social/atproto/discussions/1157 to continue the convo 👍

devinivy avatar Sep 13 '23 01:09 devinivy

Screenshot_20230913-062751

Hi! You've closed this as completed but it doesn't seem to be completed. Did you mean to close as not-planned? If that's the case, is it not planned? You've linked to a discussion which suggests it's not 👍

TodePond avatar Sep 13 '23 05:09 TodePond

The completed/planned state of gif support hasn't changed in any way, just trying to ensure all conversations around the feature are happening in one place 🙂

devinivy avatar Sep 13 '23 06:09 devinivy

Oh ok maybe best to keep it as an open issue then, so that people can see that there's an open issue for it? (and not open a new one)

TodePond avatar Sep 13 '23 06:09 TodePond

The completed/planned state of gif support hasn't changed in any way, just trying to ensure all conversations around the feature are happening in one place 🙂

so it's not completed then

jack652 avatar Feb 13 '24 00:02 jack652