Herbie icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
Herbie copied to clipboard

Drop support for Python 3.10 and ensure compatibility with 3.14

Open blaylockbk opened this issue 2 months ago • 2 comments

xarray dropped support for Python 3.10 about 4 months ago. I'd like to drop support too as soon Herbie can support Python 3.14.

blaylockbk avatar Oct 19 '25 06:10 blaylockbk

Here's some documents on how other packages are supported:

Numpy's NEP 29 gives guidance on when to drop support for older Python and packages. https://numpy.org/neps/nep-0029-deprecation_policy.html

  • Drop support for Python versions released more than 42 months ago (3.5 years)
  • Drop support for packages released more than 24 months ago (2 years)

Also, the Scientific Python community's "Minimum Supported Dependencies" has a nice table https://scientific-python.org/specs/spec-0000/

According to that table, Herbie's minimum dependencies today should be:

  • Python 3.12 (this seems a little strict, I should probably test against 3.11 too for a little while)
  • Numpy 2.0
  • Pandas 2.2
  • xarray 2023.11.0
  • scipy 1.12
  • scikit-learn 1.4

blaylockbk avatar Oct 22 '25 22:10 blaylockbk

From https://pypistats.org/packages/herbie-data, most Herbie users are using Python 3.12. A fair share use 3.11. There are much fewer people using 3.10. People have adopted 3.13 yet (that's the Python version I use).

Image

I think it's safe to say it's time to drop support for 3.10.

blaylockbk avatar Oct 22 '25 22:10 blaylockbk