bisq icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
bisq copied to clipboard

Published 20 hours ago • verified publisher icon bisq-network

Ui integration for support Trezor, Ledger, Keepkey and status-keycard

Open danimesq opened this issue 6 years ago • 8 comments

danimesq avatar Oct 03 '19 16:10 danimesq

This issue has been automatically marked as stale because it has not had recent activity. It will be closed if no further activity occurs. Thank you for your contributions.

stale[bot] avatar Jan 29 '20 13:01 stale[bot]

This issue has been automatically closed because of inactivity. Feel free to reopen it if you think it is still relevant.

stale[bot] avatar Feb 05 '20 17:02 stale[bot]

@freimair

danimesq avatar Feb 06 '20 05:02 danimesq

please

chriscrutt avatar Dec 08 '21 10:12 chriscrutt

This is an amusing discussion to an outsider like me.

Anyway, I own a Trezor and I refuse to use any software without integrated support for hardware wallets. The wiki has only one mention of a hardware wallet use.

Do not send BSQ to hardware wallets.

Is there any chance to encourage a prioritized integration of Trezor in Bisq? One idea I have is I could buy a significant amount of BSQ to fund the feature development.

MarekPasnikowski avatar Mar 09 '22 10:03 MarekPasnikowski

This is an amusing discussion to an outsider like me.

Anyway, I own a Trezor and I refuse to use any software without integrated support for hardware wallets. The wiki has only one mention of a hardware wallet use.

Do not send BSQ to hardware wallets.

Is there any chance to encourage a prioritized integration of Trezor in Bisq? One idea I have is I could buy a significant amount of BSQ to fund the feature development.

Thanks for the offer to fund this development, but it is more suited for Bisq2, which is already under development: https://github.com/bisq-network/bisq2

ripcurlx avatar Mar 09 '22 13:03 ripcurlx

I had no idea about the version 2. I will take a look at it.

MarekPasnikowski avatar Mar 09 '22 13:03 MarekPasnikowski

I have given this issue some time to think about it. I can see two distinct problems to solve:

  1. Implementation of BSQ tokens in the hardware wallets. This is the Trezor's Wiki page about new coins.

    This is what I am most interested in. I could tolerate keeping the small amounts of cryptocurrency I would want to trade outside of Trezor. However, I will not compromise the security of the long term holdings, which would include BSQ.

  2. The actual integration of hardware wallets in the BISQ application. This implies exclusive usage of hardware keys in all transactions. Definitely a big project and makes a lot of sense to do it in the BISQ2 version.

In conclusion, my main question is:

How to approach the implementation of BSQ in Trezor, and other wallets?

  • Should a random person with interest (like me) ask the wallet manufacturer to add the support?
  • Should a BISQ representative contact the manufacturer?
  • Should it be left to a developer to decide to implement it at an undefined time?

MarekPasnikowski avatar Mar 19 '22 15:03 MarekPasnikowski