github icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
github copied to clipboard

Merge 2 branches

Open akarupt opened this issue 6 years ago • 14 comments

Hi,

First of all, congrats for the atom integration with gitlab.

My "problem" at this point: I can do "git checkout branch" on the selector in atom. i can do "git pull" and "git push" on the button on atom. The only thing i need to do outside atom is the command "git merge branch". Even after i run that command i go to atom again for merge conflicts.

If there any way i can run that command inside atom?

akarupt avatar Jun 05 '18 00:06 akarupt

hi @akarupt

I believe you are correct, that Atom's git integration doesn't currently support the functionality for merging branches.

annthurium avatar Jun 18 '18 21:06 annthurium

@akarupt I use a terminal like platformio-ide-terminal to do the umpteen non supported tasks from GH package vs git, I know no other way even with git-plus etc packages that all fall short one way or another.

Interactive rebases works fine in this way as well as branch merges etc and anything else since via terminal youre talking to git directly and GH package picks up the rest to do the staged/unstaged diffs etc etc.

Im from the opinion that a terminal is essential in Atom when dealing with Git and that no UI extension is ever going to be as powerful as command line.

the-j0k3r avatar Jul 19 '18 15:07 the-j0k3r

Would love to have branch merging available in this package. As it is, GitHub Desktop can't deal with Conflicts, but can merge. Atom can't merge, but can deal with merge conflicts. So I have to use both whenever I want to merge AND deal with merge conflicts. It would be great to have merging available in this Git and Github Atom package.

JosephTLyons avatar Jul 25 '18 19:07 JosephTLyons

Merging branches in atom would be great, especially since atom already supports working with different branches. It seems a little bit odd that that's possible, but the merging tool is missing. And the merge conflict resolution in atom is just amazing - I'd preferably be able to deal with everything in there rather than having to go back and forth between github desktop / git cmd and atom.

ghost avatar Aug 09 '18 22:08 ghost

Funny though, Atom seems aware of merge. When I started merge outside of atom, Atom displayed "abort merge" button.

hleumas avatar Aug 22 '18 12:08 hleumas

This would be a very useful feature.

AlbertoFabbri93 avatar Jan 10 '20 23:01 AlbertoFabbri93

Still looking for how to achieve merges in Atom (which I love btw!). Much needed feature.

thatvirtualboy avatar Mar 12 '20 14:03 thatvirtualboy

I much love atom if they added this feature

dixcity avatar Apr 28 '20 16:04 dixcity

I too also would love if they added that feature.

MousaGhannam avatar Jul 02 '20 20:07 MousaGhannam

I too would also love if they added this very critical feature.

CircleInc avatar Feb 14 '21 08:02 CircleInc

Still waiting.

anankitpatil avatar Oct 07 '21 09:10 anankitpatil

Atom hasn't had any real development support in a few years. It is probably best to move on to the next editor.

JosephTLyons avatar Oct 07 '21 21:10 JosephTLyons

Yes, VSCode is really good AND supports merging git branches.

LewisCraik avatar Oct 08 '21 05:10 LewisCraik

Surprising indeed this isn't available in 2022

zeluspudding avatar Jan 26 '22 23:01 zeluspudding