modbot icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
modbot copied to clipboard

[suggestion] Various suggestions.

Open yiyoperez opened this issue 3 years ago • 7 comments

Why this suggestion? More info like message and user id is really important to report those players if needed.

Specify more info when logging deletes messages and bulk deleted messages, also message delete bulk event doesn't log attachments.

Some examples:

(MessageDeleteBulkEventListener) image

(MessageDeleteEmbed) image

yiyoperez avatar Dec 08 '22 00:12 yiyoperez

More info like message and user id is really important to report those players if needed.

Report them to whom? Discord generally doesn't accept message deletions logged by bots as evidence.

Specify more info when logging deletes messages and bulk deleted messages

Which information exactly would you like to see added?

also message delete bulk event doesn't log attachments.

Bulk deletes are very complicated, as they can be used to delete hundreds of messages within a very short time frame. To avoid API spam, ModBot can't just repost these messages individually. Instead, it tries to add as many of them as possible and logs that as a single message. Adding attachments to this could be possible.

JulianVennen avatar Dec 08 '22 12:12 JulianVennen

Report them to whom? Discord generally doesn't accept message deletions logged by bots as evidence.

Huh, dont't get me wrong, I don't want to use a bot log message as evidence. I mean just log the user id, message id and later use them manually fill them using Discord's message link format (https://discordapp.com/channels/xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx/xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx/xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx)

Which information exactly would you like to see added?

As I said before, message & user id also explained more in the previous reply.

Bulk deletes are very complicated, as they can be used to delete hundreds of messages within a very short time frame. To avoid API spam, ModBot can't just repost these messages individually. Instead, it tries to add as many of them as possible and logs that as a single message. Adding attachments to this could be possible.

Yes, if it could be possible it would be great since attachment gets logger when deleting a message manually but is not when deleting messages as bulk.

yiyoperez avatar Dec 08 '22 19:12 yiyoperez

To make sure that ModBot can log as many messages as possible, I really want to keep the metadata for bulk deletes short. How about this:

<user-mention> (<message-id>): <message-content>

and for messages with files:

<user-mention> (<message-id>) 7 files: <message-content>

JulianVennen avatar Dec 12 '22 17:12 JulianVennen

Bulk Delete: image

Single Message Delete: image

JulianVennen avatar Dec 12 '22 17:12 JulianVennen

Where? In the single message delete? There's no mention to click on.

JulianVennen avatar Dec 12 '22 18:12 JulianVennen

The user id is not in the new bulk delete format I proposed. The old format didn't have a user mention that you could click on.

JulianVennen avatar Dec 12 '22 18:12 JulianVennen

To make sure that ModBot can log as many messages as possible, I really want to keep the metadata for bulk deletes short. How about this:

<user-mention> (<message-id>): <message-content>

and for messages with files:

<user-mention> (<message-id>) 7 files: <message-content>

Yes! I like this proposed format, user mention in bulk format keeps the message short and clean didn't think of it before.

yiyoperez avatar Dec 12 '22 18:12 yiyoperez