Andrew Sutherland

I think any sizing logic would want to go in the HTML standard with the StructuredSerialize algorithm and friends. This could be quite useful in other specs like the Notifiations...

While it's unfortunately not unusual to optimize to a specific implementation, altering API design due to a single browser's implementation decisions runs counter to the point of web standards and...

For the explicit request: I don't think compare-and-swap is appropriate semantics to layer on top of transactions. As I understand the compare-and-swap primitive it is a general low-level multi-threading primitive...

> Looking at this again I wonder how Firefox defeats the attack. I was misunderstanding something initially. What does Firefox never collect? Maybe @asutherland can help out here. In Firefox,...

You may need to call `navigator.storage.persist()` to actually take advantage of the "unlimitedStorage" permission. There's a weird 2-step dance from the perspective of the Web API where the permissions manager...

To clarify, yes, you interpreted this right, but I think the [current HTML spec terminology](https://html.spec.whatwg.org/multipage/structured-data.html) (and [WebIDL attribute](https://html.spec.whatwg.org/multipage/structured-data.html#serializable)) is serializable, and the term [cloneable is legacy](https://html.spec.whatwg.org/multipage/structured-data.html#cloneable-objects) but reflected in terminology...

> I expect @asutherland might prefer something more efficient than this, though. I don't have a concern about efficiency. But I do have 2 different concerns: 1. Developer ergonomics. URLPattern...

To re-characterize the root of my concern: - ServiceWorker registration matching is on the critical path for navigations. - This can bias browsers to potentially need to keep all ServiceWorker...

> Close this issue, feel free to reopen if needed. (For clarity, I don't have the ability to do this.)

I'm fine for this issue to migrate to the static routing proposal. I can re-file there if its authors prefer versus them filing a more pragmatic, smaller issue. I know...