turicreate icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
turicreate copied to clipboard

Support for YOLO v3

Open b-straub opened this issue 6 years ago • 8 comments

Any plans to support YOLO v3 as object detector backend? YOLO v3

b-straub avatar Jun 11 '18 16:06 b-straub

Thanks for the feature request! Actually, even though our object detector pre-dates v3, we departed from v2 in a few ways that makes it more similar to v3. For instance, we use a softmax cross entropy loss for classes, as opposed to the regression loss in v2. Of course, there are still many differences and our model is still closer to v2.

It would be great to know in more detail why you are interested in v3. Is it purely for the impressive numbers, or are there particular aspects of v3 that you are interested in?

gustavla avatar Jun 11 '18 16:06 gustavla

I am interested in a higher accuracy for small objects. Watching this video YOLO v2 vs YOLO v3 vs Mask RCNN vs Deeplab Xception I get the feeling that YOLO v3 is indeed doing a better job.

A good place to see what I mean is at 26:30 the small cars towards the horizon.

b-straub avatar Jun 11 '18 16:06 b-straub

Great, that is really helpful to know! There are indeed efforts in v3 to tackle this that I agree we could benefit from as well (using their three tiers of scale).

gustavla avatar Jun 11 '18 17:06 gustavla

@gustavla And what about #140 ?

pcmanik avatar Jun 12 '18 08:06 pcmanik

@pcmanik Thanks for bringing your unanswered question to my attention. I answered on that issue and feel free to respond with feedback there.

gustavla avatar Jun 12 '18 16:06 gustavla

Has there been any update on this recently, or still just a pipeline dream? 🙃

willbattel avatar Jan 18 '19 12:01 willbattel

While there have been no recent updates, I would say that this is more than just a dream. Insofar as we'd definitely like to give the object detection toolkit some more love, and this is one thing to explore!

nickjong avatar Jan 18 '19 21:01 nickjong

related to #1734

TobyRoseman avatar Sep 01 '20 22:09 TobyRoseman