trafficcontrol icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
trafficcontrol copied to clipboard

Add one text field in Servers config on TP

Open tyagian opened this issue 7 years ago • 9 comments

Can we add one more form field to the servers>[server_hostname] which can be used for adding useful info like server serial number? We do have them on delivery services so adding such space to servers will also be useful.

tyagian avatar Aug 28 '18 20:08 tyagian

I'm not sure what you mean. Are you saying you want to add another field to a Server? Is this a field like server.notes?

mitchell852 avatar Aug 29 '18 14:08 mitchell852

@tyagian ^^

mitchell852 avatar Oct 16 '18 20:10 mitchell852

Yes! It's good to have a notes field in servers config. We have a couple of them in delivery services config but servers have None of them.

tyagian avatar Oct 27 '18 20:10 tyagian

Is the new data generally desirable or environment specific? If it's generally desirable we should consider adding it to our existing data model instead of an unstructured text field.

jhg03a avatar Nov 19 '18 19:11 jhg03a

FYI, I've run into another use case for this: if we had a field to store something such as serial number or MAC address for a server object in TO, it would facilitate our use of "universal" install images, where the servers bootstrap themselves automatically and get all the info they need to fully configure themselves from TOAPI. Essentially, if this worked, we could potentially do away with geniso.

guzzijason avatar Feb 15 '19 16:02 guzzijason

@mitchell852, notice the comment above. I'd love to at a minimum have a conversation about what @guzzijason mentioned. If adding this new field would lead to us being able to more easily get our new hardware up and running this should have a higher priority.

nbitzer avatar Feb 15 '19 16:02 nbitzer

i.e we would love to have new gear pre-imaged with a universal ISO before it is even racked/stacked, and let it install itself. Would save literal man-months of time on these new deploys, IMHO.

guzzijason avatar Feb 15 '19 16:02 guzzijason

There was a long discussion about this on the dev mailing list that got mostly filibustered: https://lists.apache.org/thread.html/1af20d2ed98b2d99bf64d2de1bd9c7a9ecd707038083f18cb51a839a@%3Cdev.trafficcontrol.apache.org%3E It's probably worth trying to bring up again.

dneuman64 avatar Feb 15 '19 17:02 dneuman64

FYI, I've found that ILO IP functions as an effective analog of a serial number, for host self-identification purposes. For now, I'm just going with that for the project I'm working on.

guzzijason avatar Feb 20 '19 19:02 guzzijason