pekko-http icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
pekko-http copied to clipboard

reproducible builds: TASTY differences

Open raboof opened this issue 1 year ago • 2 comments

reproducing 1.1.0-M1 with set ThisBuild / net.bzzt.reproduciblebuilds.ReproducibleBuildsPlugin.reproducibleBuildsCheckResolver := DefaultMavenRepository; ++3.3; clean; reproducibleBuildsCheck showed a nondeterminism for me in pekko-core_3-1.1.0-M1.jar :

In org/apache/pekko/http/scaladsl/model/HttpMessage.tasty there are small differences at lines 0x0000010, 0x00000020 and 0x00002d30:

<div class="diffheader"><div id="org-apache-pekko-http-scaladsl-model-HttpMessage.tasty"><span class="source">org/apache/pekko/http/scaladsl/model/HttpMessage.tasty</span>
      
    </div>
    </div>

Offset 1, 10 lines modified | Offset 1, 10 lines modified
-- | --
00000000:·5ca1·ab1f·9c83·808b·5363·616c·6120·332e··\.......Scala·3. | 00000000:·5ca1·ab1f·9c83·808b·5363·616c·6120·332e··\.......Scala·3.
00000010:·332e·3300·1e07·3cfd·e113·ee00·f50d·1e5b··3.3...<........[ | 00000010:·332e·3300·1e07·3cfd·e113·ee00·09c6·706e··3.3...<.......pn
00000020:·9b3b·2b21·d001·8441·5354·7301·836f·7267··.;+!...ASTs..org | 00000020:·f03c·2b21·d001·8441·5354·7301·836f·7267··.<+!...ASTs..org
00000030:·0186·6170·6163·6865·0282·8182·0185·7065··..apache......pe | 00000030:·0186·6170·6163·6865·0282·8182·0185·7065··..apache......pe
00000040:·6b6b·6f02·8283·8401·8468·7474·7002·8285··kko......http... | 00000040:·6b6b·6f02·8283·8401·8468·7474·7002·8285··kko......http...
00000050:·8601·8873·6361·6c61·6473·6c02·8287·8801··...scaladsl..... | 00000050:·8601·8873·6361·6c61·6473·6c02·8287·8801··...scaladsl.....
00000060:·856d·6f64·656c·0282·898a·0186·7374·7265··.model......stre | 00000060:·856d·6f64·656c·0282·898a·0186·7374·7265··.model......stre
00000070:·616d·0184·466c·6f77·0189·466c·6f77·5368··am..Flow..FlowSh | 00000070:·616d·0184·466c·6f77·0189·466c·6f77·5368··am..Flow..FlowSh
00000080:·6170·6501·8547·7261·7068·018c·4d61·7465··ape..Graph..Mate | 00000080:·6170·6501·8547·7261·7068·018c·4d61·7465··ape..Graph..Mate
00000090:·7269·616c·697a·6572·0192·5379·7374·656d··rializer..System | 00000090:·7269·616c·697a·6572·0192·5379·7374·656d··rializer..System
Offset 717, 15 lines modified | Offset 717, 15 lines modified
00002cc0:·fb80·9795·9580·9789·8680·9785·af87·9787··................ | 00002cc0:·fb80·9795·9580·9789·8680·9785·af87·9787··................
00002cd0:·fe99·93f5·9493·fb8b·93f7·8693·fb80·97a4··................ | 00002cd0:·fe99·93f5·9493·fb8b·93f7·8693·fb80·97a4··................
00002ce0:·a080·9782·a587·9787·fe8b·93ef·8693·fb80··................ | 00002ce0:·a080·9782·a587·9787·fe8b·93ef·8693·fb80··................
00002cf0:·979c·9880·9782·9187·9787·fe80·9788·8280··................ | 00002cf0:·979c·9880·9782·9187·9787·fe80·9788·8280··................
00002d00:·9783·a187·9787·f886·93f5·8097·9193·8097··................ | 00002d00:·9783·a187·9787·f886·93f5·8097·9193·8097··................
00002d10:·88a3·8797·87fe·9193·f786·93f5·8097·9a96··................ | 00002d10:·88a3·8797·87fe·9193·f786·93f5·8097·9a96··................
00002d20:·8097·00c1·0051·e58d·0234·818d·ba7f·2edb··.....Q...4...... | 00002d20:·8097·00c1·0051·e58d·0234·818d·ba7f·2edb··.....Q...4......
00002d30:·b001·a68d·8db0·00d8·8403·de00·c8b0·7d48··..............}H | 00002d30:·b000·de8d·8d84·03de·00c8·b001·a0b0·7d48··..............}H
00002d40:·9e94·0051·9600·da7f·2efe·a07f·a6ec·eca7··...Q............ | 00002d40:·9e94·0051·9600·da7f·2efe·a07f·a6ec·eca7··...Q............
00002d50:·94a2·8393·f480·00df·9300·cf85·9d8a·8096··................ | 00002d50:·94a2·8393·f480·00df·9300·cf85·9d8a·8096··................
00002d60:·83cf·abb1·8093·da80·bf8e·a485·9d8c·9193··................ | 00002d60:·83cf·abb1·8093·da80·bf8e·a485·9d8c·9193··................
00002d70:·fb80·8bfb·80af·9a9d·849d·8a80·00cf·889a··................ | 00002d70:·fb80·8bfb·80af·9a9d·849d·8a80·00cf·889a··................
00002d80:·849d·8f80·b78a·9a84·9d90·80af·8baa·849d··................ | 00002d80:·849d·8f80·b78a·9a84·9d90·80af·8baa·849d··................
00002d90:·8d80·93f4·8a93·fc80·978e·8f80·bf8e·ab84··................ | 00002d90:·8d80·93f4·8a93·fc80·978e·8f80·bf8e·ab84··................
00002da0:·9d90·8093·ec80·00cf·8490·8093·fd80·bf8d··................ | 00002da0:·9d90·8093·ec80·00cf·8490·8093·fd80·bf8d··................

org/apache/pekko/http/scaladsl/model/HttpEntity.tasty is also different, and here the differences are larger.

Filed https://github.com/scala/scala3/issues/21154

raboof avatar Jun 07 '24 08:06 raboof

(looks like this missed the train for 3.3.4 but will likely be backported to LTS in 3.3.5)

raboof avatar Jul 25 '24 07:07 raboof

Looking at this again I'm not so sure we can expect all of this to be fixed in 3.3.5, but let's see.

We encountered it in the 1.1.0 release again: https://arnout.engelen.eu/reproducible-builds-diffoscope-output-pekko-http-core_3-1.1.0.jar/

raboof avatar Oct 01 '24 10:10 raboof