apache
cmake(bugfix): sync CMake SIM Toolchain file
Summary
- Synchronize CMake's SIM arch Toolchain file and Makefile versions to be consistent
Impact
Synchronous build system, not a new feature
Testing
All sim build
[Experimental Bot, please feedback here]
No, this PR does not fully meet the NuttX requirements.
Here's why and how to improve it:
- Summary:
- Missing "Why": The summary states WHAT is being changed but not WHY. Is there a specific problem caused by the versions being out of sync? Does this improve maintainability? Be explicit about the benefit.
- Impact:
- Too Brief: While stating "Synchronous build system, not a new feature" is a start, it lacks detail. Even if no user-facing changes occur, be thorough:
- Build Impact: Does this change any build flags, dependencies, or the build process itself?
- Hardware: Explicitly confirm "NO" impact on any hardware architectures or boards.
- Documentation: Does this change necessitate any updates to build instructions or documentation? Even if "NO", state it.
- Compatibility: Be explicit about backward and forward compatibility. Does this change affect how the build system interacts with older NuttX versions or tools?
- Too Brief: While stating "Synchronous build system, not a new feature" is a start, it lacks detail. Even if no user-facing changes occur, be thorough:
- Testing:
- Insufficient Detail: "All sim build" is not descriptive enough.
- Host Details: List the specific operating system(s) and compiler(s) used for building.
- Target Details: Specify the simulator(s) used (e.g., QEMU, Renode) and any relevant configurations.
- Logs: The testing logs sections are empty. Provide actual logs or output demonstrating the issue before the change and the successful outcome after the change.
- Insufficient Detail: "All sim build" is not descriptive enough.
Example Improvements
Summary:
Synchronize CMake and Makefile Toolchain Versions for SIM Arch
This change ensures version consistency between the CMake and Makefile-based build systems for the SIM (simulator) architecture, preventing potential build issues and improving maintainability.
Impact:
- New Feature: NO
- User Impact: NO
- Build Impact: NO. The build process and required flags remain unchanged.
- Hardware Impact: NO. This change only affects the simulator build environment.
- Documentation Impact: NO. No documentation updates are required.
- Security Impact: NO
- Compatibility Impact:
- Backward Compatibility: YES. This change is compatible with previous NuttX versions.
- Forward Compatibility: N/A
- Other Considerations: None.
Testing:
Build Host: * OS: Ubuntu 20.04 * Compiler: GCC 9.4.0
Target: * Architecture: SIM * Simulator: QEMU (qemu-system-arm)
Testing Logs Before Change:
[Provide actual build logs showing inconsistency or errors]Testing Logs After Change:
[Provide build logs demonstrating successful, consistent builds]
@xuxin930 hi, could you look at this issue https://github.com/apache/nuttx/issues/14413 ? it looks like this PR is to blame
