airflow-site icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
airflow-site copied to clipboard

The buttons for the Use Cases feel reversed

Open LeonY1 opened this issue 4 years ago • 7 comments

In the Use Cases tab, if you click on one of the companies, it doesn't feel intuitive to press previous to move to the next company to the right and vice versa.

This could be my personal opinion, but this feels very confusing when I use it.

LeonY1 avatar Aug 06 '20 03:08 LeonY1

There are two buttons after the use case: previous and next. I think it's quite intuitive that those refer to navigation between other use cases. Happy to hear other opinions, eventually we can ask the UX designer behind this design :)

turbaszek avatar Aug 07 '20 05:08 turbaszek

Its intuitive that they're for navigation but not that previous goes to the right and next goes to the left.

LeonY1 avatar Aug 07 '20 13:08 LeonY1

@LeonY1 Can you take a screenshot and highlight which page item you are talking about? I can't find the problem either.

mik-laj avatar Aug 09 '20 13:08 mik-laj

When we look at the use cases page we can see that there are a lot of different use cases ordered from left to right. So the example I will be talking about will be between Adobe and Big Fish games. Since they're ordered from left to right, it would make sense that the next use case would be to the right since that is how the array was ordered.

UseCases

Adobe

So when we enter the Adobe use case, it would make more sense to go to next since there hasn't been any previous already. However, this is not the case. You will have to use previous to move to the Big Fish games.

Adobe

Big Fish

And in converse to that, you will need to press next to move to the previous option.

BigFish

This also mixes up your original pattern thinking of the right side goes to the next available one in the array while the left one goes to the previous one.

I believe this could have been thought to be previous and next in the order they've been added but since there's no date or anything of that sort, this can be seen to be very confusing. This was just my opinion on the site; however, I think that others would definitely have some sort of confusion when seeing this

LeonY1 avatar Aug 09 '20 14:08 LeonY1

@turbaszek @mik-laj What is your opinion on this?

LeonY1 avatar Aug 11 '20 14:08 LeonY1

@LeonY1 I forwarded your ticket to our UX & UI Design studio. They are not very active on GH, but I hope they will come back to us soon with their opinion.

CC: @kgabryje

mik-laj avatar Aug 11 '20 14:08 mik-laj

@ryanahamilton maybe you can look at this one too - quick fix

ryw avatar Nov 03 '20 14:11 ryw