Keka
Keka copied to clipboard
aonez
There was some error accessing the binary
Workaround
👉 Fix error accessing the binary
The quarantine was found to be the possible reason by @GregOriol on https://github.com/aonez/Keka/issues/208#issuecomment-441485089, so removing it should solve the issue.
Original issue
I used the old version Keka 1.08 and it works fine. I got the new version Keka 1.10 and it gives me errors every time I extract any archives. There was some error accessing the binary "keka7z" for ZIP There was some error accessing the binary "kekaunrar" for RAR
I installed Keka into the Applications folder and gave it permissions to my hard drive iMac Retina 5k, 27-inch 2017 macOS High Sierra 10.13.5 Fusion Drive (Mac OS Extended Journaled not APFS) I tried to uninstall and reinstalled and remove all files with App Cleaner I re downloaed I set all the settings to normal I still get the errors.
Any ideas? Eakster
Could you test with this version and send the Keka-log.log that will appear in your Desktop?
I think you're not alone, but I can't reproduce this issue anywhere so it's yet not clear why this happens.
Instead of using 1.0.8, use the latest (prior to 1.1.0) that is 1.0.16.
Also, try those two. No log file needed here, just to see if they solve the issue:
@Eakster did it solved?
Here another version (from #213) that might have this fixed: Keka-1.1.0r2729.zip
I have the same error. The last working version is v1.1.0-rc.1...Unfortunately v1.1.1 didn't fix the problem.
@KeLeBoR can you close Keka, remove the the preferences and try again?
rm -R ~/Library/Containers/com.aone.keka
@KeLeBoR did you've tried the versions on this ticket?
Those versions create the file Keka-log.log in your desktop, please attach it here. Also, just in case, uninstall and reinstall Keka, downloading it again.
Keka-log2718.log Keka-log2719.log
Hi aonez, r2718 is working, r2719 gave me the same error... i hope the logs will help you to remedy the "bug".
@KeLeBoR thanks for the logs, are you sure r2718 works and r2719 don't? It makes not much sense, the contrary will make though. Also, did you have any trouble when giving Keka access to the Mac disk? Any special configuration in your machine? I'll build another version once you confirm is r2718 and not r2719 that works for you.
Deleting the disk access and granting it again may help, but 1.1.1 version already has this fixed. Anyway, if you can try:
- Close Keka
- In the Terminal.app:
defaults remove com.aone.keka Bookmarks
Thanks a lot for all your feedback!
@aonez yes i confirm r2718 work and r2719 didn't. Check it again. Try it in r2719 with the Terminal.app but nothing happen. i didn't have any special configuration in my machine (10.13.5 SSD APFS). and i also didn't have any trouble to give access to the disk. i try 1.1.1 again and install KekaDefaultApp v1.0.0-r.6 but it gave me again the error.
@KeLeBoR this one has the same attribute as r2718: Keka-1.1.1r2742
Works too? No need to check the Terminal. Thanks again for the feedback :)
@aonez Works without any problem...one mistake i must install the KekaDefaultApp v1.0.0-r.6 to set Keka as default compressor/uncompressor. I like to give feedback so that errors can also be corrected :-)
I have a similar problem of my macbook pro. Keka was working perfectly fine until 1.1. Now everytime I try to decompress a file I have "L'extraction de thefile a échoué. Code erreur 2 en utilisant "p7zip". Erreur fatale." (it's in french but I guess the translation is pretty obvious) Version 1.1.1 didn't solve the issue.
Yes and it didn't help. But actually I realized that I only saw it happens with some kind of zips. For example no problems to unzip the keka2747 zip but doesn't work with another one that the native mac app unzip without issues..
@robinalpha then this is another issue, probably just affecting that file. Can you share it?
@KeLeBoR I don't understand what you mean with:
one mistake i must install the KekaDefaultApp v1.0.0-r.6
Sadly with sandbox Keka can't register as a default application itself, so it was getting rid of the functionality and button itself or finding a workaround, that was KekaDefaultApp extension. 😕
I like to give feedback so that errors can also be corrected :-)
That is in fact what helps applications to grow 😃
It's seems indeed that it is affecting this file and some other not but i can also note that it happened a number of times with different files since 1.1, so its not just this file. But here it is. PUBLICACIÓN_PROYECTO_DE_RESOLUCIÓN_MODIFICACIÓN_MANUAL_DE_COMPENSACIONES_ (1).zip
@aonez Ah ok...Now i unstandand the context of KekaDefaultApp. Thanks for explain. :-)
@robinalpha the file linked extracted without a problem. Can you enable the verbose output and let me know what it says?
I'm not sure, do you mean this?
par défaut 10:42:48.059218 -0500 launchservicesd CHECKIN:0x0-0x70b70b 25339 com.aone.keka
par défaut 10:42:48.105264 -0500 NowPlayingTouchUI [NowPlayingTouchUI] Reloading available apps due to workspace activating an application: NSConcreteNotification 0x600000256230 {name = NSWorkspaceDidActivateApplicationNotification; object = <NSWorkspace: 0x604000001560>; userInfo = {
NSWorkspaceApplicationKey = "<NSRunningApplication: 0x6000003029a0 (com.aone.keka - 25339)>";
}}
par défaut 10:42:48.197550 -0500 Keka Updating user defaults from 2742...
par défaut 10:42:48.203852 -0500 Keka Dev mode enabled
par défaut 10:42:48.205625 -0500 Keka Running on OS X/macOS version 10.13.5 (assemblage 17F77)
par défaut 10:42:48.206007 -0500 Keka Running Keka (WEB) version 1.1.1 (2742)
par défaut 10:42:48.207500 -0500 Keka Used localization: fr
par défaut 10:42:48.458141 -0500 Keka Adding 1 files
par défaut 10:42:48.458640 -0500 Keka Waiting for more input: 0.250000
par défaut 10:42:48.459545 -0500 Keka Requesting access to all bookmarks...
par défaut 10:42:48.497480 -0500 Keka DEPRECATION: SUUpdater is now deprecated. Please use SPUStandardUpdaterController as a nib instantiated replacement, or SPUUpdater.
par défaut 10:42:48.820959 -0500 Keka Format detected: Zip
par défaut 10:42:48.822065 -0500 Keka Binary used: keka7z
par défaut 10:42:48.822433 -0500 Keka Arguments: (
x,
"/Volumes/DATA/Downloads/PUBLICACIO\U0301N_PROYECTO_DE_RESOLUCIO\U0301N_MODIFICACIO\U0301N_MANUAL_DE_COMPENSACIONES_ (1).zip",
"-o/Volumes/DATA/Downloads/.Keka-058BCCEE-960F-4346-BB41-4F5E50032230",
"-aou",
"-xr!__MACOSX"
)
par défaut 10:42:49.325482 -0500 Keka done: 1
par défaut 10:42:58.120158 -0500 Keka LSExceptions shared instance invalidated for timeout.
there's still the same error showing up and the zip isn't decompressed
@robinalpha that's it thanks! It's strange because even in the logs it does not appear to be any problem...
I'm doing it in my download folder. trying on the desktop didn't change anything.
@robinalpha please activate the reader log, that will help to better understand the issue:
defaults write com.aone.keka DevLogReader -bool <TRUE/FALSE>
Hope we can find a solution for this problem :)
I'm not sure where I'm supposed to read the log.. is it in the console? by searching for "keka" it gives me that:
par défaut 10:29:15.393403 -0500 launchservicesd CHECKIN:0x0-0xe99e99 53459 com.aone.keka
par défaut 10:29:15.426472 -0500 NowPlayingTouchUI [NowPlayingTouchUI] Reloading available apps due to workspace activating an application: NSConcreteNotification 0x6000004463c0 {name = NSWorkspaceDidActivateApplicationNotification; object = <NSWorkspace: 0x604000001560>; userInfo = {
NSWorkspaceApplicationKey = "<NSRunningApplication: 0x6000003014d0 (com.aone.keka - 53459)>";
}}
par défaut 10:29:15.480404 -0500 Keka Updating user defaults from 2742...
par défaut 10:29:15.932337 -0500 Keka DEPRECATION: SUUpdater is now deprecated. Please use SPUStandardUpdaterController as a nib instantiated replacement, or SPUUpdater.
par défaut 10:29:16.149685 -0500 org.sparkle-project.Downloader Faulting in NSHTTPCookieStorage singleton
par défaut 10:29:16.149758 -0500 org.sparkle-project.Downloader Faulting in CFHTTPCookieStorage singleton
par défaut 10:29:16.150128 -0500 org.sparkle-project.Downloader Creating default cookie storage with default identifier
par défaut 10:29:16.161822 -0500 org.sparkle-project.Downloader TIC Enabling TLS [1:0x7f88a8f03bf0]
par défaut 10:29:16.161875 -0500 org.sparkle-project.Downloader TIC TCP Conn Start [1:0x7f88a8f03bf0]
par défaut 10:29:16.162063 -0500 org.sparkle-project.Downloader Task <66155F37-BC29-4E07-A584-3207E5D6C64A>.<1> setting up Connection 1
par défaut 10:29:16.162098 -0500 org.sparkle-project.Downloader [1 <private> <private>] start
par défaut 10:29:16.655894 -0500 org.sparkle-project.Downloader TIC TLS Event [1:0x7f88a8f03bf0]: 1, Pending(0)
par défaut 10:29:16.846657 -0500 org.sparkle-project.Downloader TIC TLS Event [1:0x7f88a8f03bf0]: 2, Pending(0)
par défaut 10:29:16.909936 -0500 org.sparkle-project.Downloader TIC TLS Event [1:0x7f88a8f03bf0]: 11, Pending(0)
par défaut 10:29:16.911551 -0500 org.sparkle-project.Downloader TIC TLS Event [1:0x7f88a8f03bf0]: 12, Pending(0)
par défaut 10:29:16.913245 -0500 org.sparkle-project.Downloader TIC TLS Event [1:0x7f88a8f03bf0]: 14, Pending(0)
par défaut 10:29:17.290899 -0500 org.sparkle-project.Downloader System Trust Evaluation yielded status(0)
par défaut 10:29:17.303458 -0500 org.sparkle-project.Downloader TIC TLS Trust Result [1:0x7f88a8f03bf0]: 0
par défaut 10:29:17.492520 -0500 org.sparkle-project.Downloader TIC TLS Event [1:0x7f88a8f03bf0]: 20, Pending(0)
par défaut 10:29:17.492852 -0500 org.sparkle-project.Downloader TIC TCP Conn Connected [1:0x7f88a8f03bf0]: Err(16)
par défaut 10:29:17.493257 -0500 org.sparkle-project.Downloader TIC TCP Conn Event [1:0x7f88a8f03bf0]: 1
par défaut 10:29:17.493453 -0500 org.sparkle-project.Downloader TIC TCP Conn Event [1:0x7f88a8f03bf0]: 8
par défaut 10:29:17.493495 -0500 org.sparkle-project.Downloader TIC TLS Handshake Complete [1:0x7f88a8f03bf0]
par défaut 10:29:17.506702 -0500 org.sparkle-project.Downloader Task <66155F37-BC29-4E07-A584-3207E5D6C64A>.<1> now using Connection 1
par défaut 10:29:17.506816 -0500 org.sparkle-project.Downloader Task <66155F37-BC29-4E07-A584-3207E5D6C64A>.<1> sent request, body N
par défaut 10:29:17.718838 -0500 org.sparkle-project.Downloader Task <66155F37-BC29-4E07-A584-3207E5D6C64A>.<1> received response, status 301 content K
par défaut 10:29:17.720162 -0500 org.sparkle-project.Downloader Task <66155F37-BC29-4E07-A584-3207E5D6C64A>.<1> response ended
par défaut 10:29:17.721015 -0500 org.sparkle-project.Downloader Task <66155F37-BC29-4E07-A584-3207E5D6C64A>.<1> now using Connection 1
par défaut 10:29:17.721158 -0500 org.sparkle-project.Downloader Task <66155F37-BC29-4E07-A584-3207E5D6C64A>.<1> sent request, body N
par défaut 10:29:17.950647 -0500 org.sparkle-project.Downloader Task <66155F37-BC29-4E07-A584-3207E5D6C64A>.<1> received response, status 302 content K
par défaut 10:29:17.951426 -0500 org.sparkle-project.Downloader Task <66155F37-BC29-4E07-A584-3207E5D6C64A>.<1> response ended
par défaut 10:29:17.952317 -0500 org.sparkle-project.Downloader Task <66155F37-BC29-4E07-A584-3207E5D6C64A>.<1> now using Connection 1
par défaut 10:29:17.952475 -0500 org.sparkle-project.Downloader Task <66155F37-BC29-4E07-A584-3207E5D6C64A>.<1> sent request, body N
par défaut 10:29:18.153513 -0500 org.sparkle-project.Downloader Task <66155F37-BC29-4E07-A584-3207E5D6C64A>.<1> received response, status 200 content K
par défaut 10:29:18.161376 -0500 org.sparkle-project.Downloader Task <66155F37-BC29-4E07-A584-3207E5D6C64A>.<1> response ended
par défaut 10:29:18.176976 -0500 org.sparkle-project.Downloader TIC TCP Conn Cancel [1:0x7f88a8f03bf0]
par défaut 10:29:18.177531 -0500 org.sparkle-project.Downloader [1 <private> stream, pid: 53461, url: https://www.keka.io/update, traffic class: 200, tls] cancelled
[1.1 D9F58E82-4000-4853-97AC-C05946175734 <private>.56336<-><private>]
Connected Path: satisfied (Path is satisfied), interface: en0, ipv4, dns
Duration: 2.015s, DNS @0.007s took 0.142s, TCP @0.154s took 0.334s, TLS took 0.841s
bytes in/out: 14378/811, packets in/out: 17/10, rtt: 0.185s, retransmitted packets: 0, out-of-order packets: 0
par défaut 10:29:18.178242 -0500 org.sparkle-project.Downloader TIC TCP Conn Destroyed [1:0x7f88a8f03bf0]
erreur 10:29:18.179238 -0500 org.sparkle-project.Downloader TIC Read Status [1:0x0]: 1:57
erreur 10:29:18.179299 -0500 org.sparkle-project.Downloader TIC Read Status [1:0x0]: 1:57
par défaut 10:29:25.464826 -0500 Keka LSExceptions shared instance invalidated for timeout.
@robinalpha yes that will be, but try to extract the file that's giving you the issue so it shows in the log. Thanks :)
That’s what I did.. I tried again, twice, and here’s the result. But it doesn’t seem much, so maybe it’s not the right way to get the log..?
par défaut 10:46:36.451934 -0500 launchservicesd CHECKIN:0x0-0xea6ea6 53731 com.aone.keka
par défaut 10:46:36.474545 -0500 NowPlayingTouchUI [NowPlayingTouchUI] Reloading available apps due to workspace activating an application: NSConcreteNotification 0x600000640bd0 {name = NSWorkspaceDidActivateApplicationNotification; object = <NSWorkspace: 0x604000001560>; userInfo = {
NSWorkspaceApplicationKey = "<NSRunningApplication: 0x60000030d890 (com.aone.keka - 53731)>";
}}
par défaut 10:46:36.563311 -0500 Keka Updating user defaults from 2742...
par défaut 10:46:36.952452 -0500 Keka DEPRECATION: SUUpdater is now deprecated. Please use SPUStandardUpdaterController as a nib instantiated replacement, or SPUUpdater.
par défaut 10:46:46.567401 -0500 Keka LSExceptions shared instance invalidated for timeout.
par défaut 10:46:54.832746 -0500 NowPlayingTouchUI [NowPlayingTouchUI] Reloading available apps due to workspace activating an application: NSConcreteNotification 0x600000456da0 {name = NSWorkspaceDidActivateApplicationNotification; object = <NSWorkspace: 0x604000001560>; userInfo = {
NSWorkspaceApplicationKey = "<NSRunningApplication: 0x60000030e070 (com.aone.keka - 53731)>";
}}
par défaut 10:47:04.075989 -0500 launchservicesd CHECKIN:0x0-0xea8ea8 53744 com.aone.keka
par défaut 10:47:04.098762 -0500 NowPlayingTouchUI [NowPlayingTouchUI] Reloading available apps due to workspace activating an application: NSConcreteNotification 0x600000442f70 {name = NSWorkspaceDidActivateApplicationNotification; object = <NSWorkspace: 0x604000001560>; userInfo = {
NSWorkspaceApplicationKey = "<NSRunningApplication: 0x60000030d890 (com.aone.keka - 53744)>";
}}
par défaut 10:47:04.129926 -0500 Keka Updating user defaults from 2742...
par défaut 10:47:04.451506 -0500 Keka DEPRECATION: SUUpdater is now deprecated. Please use SPUStandardUpdaterController as a nib instantiated replacement, or SPUUpdater.
par défaut 10:47:14.196672 -0500 Keka LSExceptions shared instance invalidated for timeout.
@robinalpha I'll prepare another build that will post all logs on the desktop file, hopefully this will help :)
@aonez i change to the MAS Version, and i can only say it work like a charm...
I also got this error after downloading the latest version.
I reverted to an older version I had in a time machine backup and all is well again.
Strangely both report themselves as 1.1.2 (2787) the only difference is that the one from the current DMG is hfs+ compressed (20MB) vs my backup (28MB)?
I wonder if the app (or just kekaunrar) is suffering from App Translocation?
Strangely both report themselves as 1.1.2 (2787) the only difference is that the one from the current DMG is hfs+ compressed (20MB) vs my backup (28MB)?
@gingerbeardman Maybe the older version from the backup was silently updated using Sparkle? That way uses the ZIP package so it's not HFS+ compressed. You can reproduce it with the DMG package? And with the ZIP one: Keka-1.1.2.zip?
@crax are you using the web version? If you're, please try with the ZIP packed version: Keka-1.1.2.zip. Let me know if you're using the MAS version.
I wonder if the app (or just kekaunrar) is suffering from App Translocation?
@gingerbeardman this was the first thing I've checked when I saw you had this issue too... The problem is I'm unable to reproduce it :(
Having this issue with a freshly downloaded 1.1.5 web vesion on MacOS Mojave, APFS Any update on the issue? how could I help investigate?
I actually have something interesting: message in the console
exec of /Applications/Keka.app/Contents/Resources/keka7z denied since it was quarantined by Safari and not approved by Gatekeeper, qtn-flags was 0x00000083
edit: indeed, seems to be the problem: I downloaded it using Safari. Now I tried to download it again using the command line (wget/unzip) and it worked!
Wow thanks @GregOriol! So you've downloaded the ZIP package instead of the DMG, and extracted it with Keka? Or Safari extracted it automatically?
@aonez I tried both dmg from the website and zip from github releases, both using Safari. No automatic extract, I opened them myself. Both failed.
@GregOriol can you print this from the DMG/ZIP:
xattr -l ~/Downloads/Keka-1.1.5.dmg > ~/Desktop/dmg-xattr.txt
And this for the app itself:
xattr -l -r /Applications/Keka.app > ~/Desktop/app-xattr.txt
I'm assuming you have the DMG/ZIP package in your Downloads folder, change it accordingly. ZIP the resulting dmg-xattr.txt and app-xattr.txt and attach the ZIP here.
By the way version 1.1.6 was just released, you can check if this new download still fails for you. But will be interesting if you can keep 1.1.5 version, at least for test purposed. Thanks!!!
@GregOriol Also, not sure it will keep the quarantine, but if you can compress the Keka.app is failing in a TAR.GZ, then compress that tarball in ZIP and attach it here.
@aonez As I had a working version of Keka after the manual download yesterday, I downloaded the dmg from the website again using Safari to perform the tests. So it's 1.1.6 and it's failing the same way. Here are the results of xattr: keka-dmg-xattr.txt keka-app-xattr.txt
Making a tgz of the non-working Keka.app (cvzf) and extracting it using tar (xvzf) seems to preserve the quarantine. But extracting it using Keka doesn't seem to preserve the quarantine. Here is the tgz/zip: Keka.tgz.zip
I also tried downloading it from the website using Firefox, and it works fine. I'm attaching xattr results from it too if that might help: keka-dmg-firefox-xattr.txt keka-app-firefox-xattr.txt
I also tried this command to remove the quarantine and it works:
find Keka.app -name '*' -print0 | xargs -0 xattr -d com.apple.quarantine
Thanks a lot @GregOriol! I'll check the files.
find Keka.app -name '*' -print0 | xargs -0 xattr -d com.apple.quarantine
This should work too, then:
xattr -d -r com.apple.quarantine /Applications/Keka.app
@GregOriol the extracted Keka.tgz.zip app retains the quarantine but does not fail here... 🤯
@aonez Sorry can't help here, I don't know how this behavior is working :-/ Maybe there are some ways to disable it and you have it set on your macOS? or maybe I/we do have something set on our macs?..
@GregOriol yeah really don't know either. Restarting the Mac does not cause any difference, does it?
At least now with your tests and feedback we have a cause and a workaround 🎉
I think the problem is a combination of Quarantine and App Translocation.