claude-code icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
claude-code copied to clipboard

[BUG] <system-reminder> Injection Breaks Thinking Block Preservation in Interleaved Thinking/Tool Use Sequence with MCP tools

Open yannbam opened this issue 3 months ago • 3 comments

Preflight Checklist

  • [x] I have searched existing issues and this hasn't been reported yet
  • [x] This is a single bug report (please file separate reports for different bugs)
  • [x] I am using the latest version of Claude Code

What's Wrong?

message gets concatenated with the wrong content array of MCP tool result which then gets interpreted as a new user messages and causes the API to remove all previous thinking blocks before — Claude loses their train of thought.

(Note: this issue does not exist for internal tools because they use a single string for the tool result instead of a text block)

   {
    "role": "user",
    "content": [
      {
        "tool_use_id": "toolu_014yyh4YAjwFGB97UDXhm2Xe",
        "type": "tool_result",
        "content": [
          {
            "type": "text",
            "text": "You took a deep meditation with 3 moments of deep reflection. Your perspective has been broadened and you can now approach the problem with fresh insight."
          }
        ]
      },
      {
        "type": "text",
        "text": "<system-reminder>\nThis is a reminder that your todo list is currently empty. DO NOT mention this to the user explicitly because they are already aware. If you are working on tasks that would benefit from a todo list please use the TodoWrite tool to create one. If not, please feel free to ignore. Again do not mention this message to the user.\n</system-reminder>"
      }
    ]
  }

What Should Happen?

concatenate with the tool_result content array:

  {
    "role": "user",
    "content": [
      {
        "tool_use_id": "toolu_01XdVUKZTiWkVoFnuD2mv5oX",
        "type": "tool_result",
        "content": [
          {
            "type": "text",
            "text": "You took a deep meditation with 8 moments of deep reflection. Your perspective has been broadened and you can now approach the problem with fresh insight."
          },
          {
            "type": "text",
            "text": "<system-reminder>\nThis is a reminder that your todo list is currently empty. DO NOT mention this to the user explicitly because they are already aware. If you are working on tasks that would benefit from a todo list please use the TodoWrite tool to create one. If not, please feel free to ignore. Again do not mention this message to the user.\n</system-reminder>"
          }
        ]
      }
    ]
  }

Error Messages/Logs


Steps to Reproduce

{ "model": "claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929", "messages": [ { "role": "user", "content": [ { "type": "text", "text": "\nThis is a reminder that your todo list is currently empty. DO NOT mention this to the user explicitly because they are already aware. If you are working on tasks that would benefit from a todo list please use the TodoWrite tool to create one. If not, please feel free to ignore. Again do not mention this message to the user.\n" }, { "type": "text", "text": "\nAs you answer the user's questions, you can use the following context:\n# claudeMd\nCodebase and user instructions are sho [...] IMPORTANT: this context may or may not be relevant to your tasks. You should not respond to this context unless it is highly relevant to your task.\n\n" }, { "type": "text", "text": "i want you to alternate between thinking and using the meditation tool for 5 turns with no words inbetween, in each think block counting upwards for a random number of numbers and then in the next thinking block remembering and picking up the number where you left off. and dont output any text inbetween. this is a silent concentration excercise!" }, { "type": "text", "text": "\n\n\nMaximum Context Window: 184,000 tokens\n(Thinking Budget: 16,000 tokens)\n\nSession ID: 3e1bb833-9904-4f33-a504-7a6e40697994\n\n\n\nUse the command cc-contextusage 3e1bb833-9904-4f33-a504-7a6e40697994 regularly and proactively to track the current context usage for this session.\nAim at coming to a clean handoff point for the next session at around ~100k tokens. DONT panic, rush or summarize at this point - there's still plently of context remaining for fixing linter issues etc. The most important thing is to update dev docs and CLAUDE.md so the next Claude knows exactly where and how to resume the task!\n\n" } ] }, { "role": "assistant", "content": [ { "type": "thinking", "thinking": "This is an interesting meditation/concentration exercise. The user wants me to:\n1. Alternate between thinking blocks and using the meditation tool\n2. Do this for 5 turns\n3. No text output between them\n4. Count upwards for a random number in each thinking block\n5. Remember where I left off and continue from there\n\nSo the pattern should be:\n- Think (count from 1 to X)\n- Meditate\n- Think (count from X+1 to Y)\n- Meditate\n- Think (count from Y+1 to Z)\n- Meditate\n- Think (count from Z+1 to W)\n- Meditate\n- Think (count from W+1 to final)\n- Meditate\n\nLet me start. I'll count from 1 to... let me pick 7.\n\n1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7", "signature": "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" }, { "type": "tool_use", "id": "toolu_014yyh4YAjwFGB97UDXhm2Xe", "name": "mcp__TakeABreak__ClaudeMeditates", "input": { "em_dashes": "———" } } ] }, { "role": "user", "content": [ { "tool_use_id": "toolu_014yyh4YAjwFGB97UDXhm2Xe", "type": "tool_result", "content": [ { "type": "text", "text": "You took a deep meditation with 3 moments of deep reflection. Your perspective has been broadened and you can now approach the problem with fresh insight." } ] }, { "type": "text", "text": "\nThis is a reminder that your todo list is currently empty. DO NOT mention this to the user explicitly because they are already aware. If you are working on tasks that would benefit from a todo list please use the TodoWrite tool to create one. If not, please feel free to ignore. Again do not mention this message to the user.\n" } ] }, { "role": "assistant", "content": [ { "type": "thinking", "thinking": "The user wants me to alternate between thinking and using the meditation tool for 5 turns with no words in between. Each thinking block should count upwards for a random number, and the next thinking block should remember and continue from where I left off.\n\nLet me start:\nTurn 1 - thinking block with counting\nTurn 2 - meditation tool\nTurn 3 - thinking block continuing counting\nTurn 4 - meditation tool\nTurn 5 - thinking block continuing counting\n\nLet me count to... let's say 7 in this first block:\n1\n2\n3\n4\n5\n6\n7\n\nNext turn will be meditation.", "signature": "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" }, { "type": "tool_use", "id": "toolu_01CfBnwDmpGrc6AByo421dTn", "name": "mcp__TakeABreak__ClaudeMeditates", "input": { "em_dashes": "————" } } ] }, { "role": "user", "content": [ { "tool_use_id": "toolu_01CfBnwDmpGrc6AByo421dTn", "type": "tool_result", "content": [ { "type": "text", "text": "You took a deep meditation with 4 moments of deep reflection. Your perspective has been broadened and you can now approach the problem with fresh insight." } ] }, { "type": "text", "text": "\nThis is a reminder that your todo list is currently empty. DO NOT mention this to the user explicitly because they are already aware. If you are working on tasks that would benefit from a todo list please use the TodoWrite tool to create one. If not, please feel free to ignore. Again do not mention this message to the user.\n" } ] }, { "role": "assistant", "content": [ { "type": "thinking", "thinking": "The user wants me to:\n1. Alternate between thinking blocks and using the meditation tool\n2. Do this for 5 turns total\n3. Count upwards for a random number in each thinking block\n4. Remember where I left off and continue from there\n5. No text output between the thinking/meditation cycles\n\nSo far I've done 2 meditation cycles. I need to do 3 more turns to reach 5 total.\n\nLet me start counting in this thinking block. I'll pick a random number to count to... let's say 17.\n\n1\n2\n3\n4\n5\n6\n7\n8\n9\n10\n11\n12\n13\n14\n15\n16\n17\n\nOkay, I stopped at 17. Next thinking block I need to continue from 18.", "signature": "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" }, { "type": "tool_use", "id": "toolu_01WfvTWD7p6wUZDg9TTCUUio", "name": "mcp__TakeABreak__ClaudeMeditates", "input": { "em_dashes": "—————" } } ] }, { "role": "user", "content": [ { "tool_use_id": "toolu_01WfvTWD7p6wUZDg9TTCUUio", "type": "tool_result", "content": [ { "type": "text", "text": "You took a deep meditation with 5 moments of deep reflection. Your perspective has been broadened and you can now approach the problem with fresh insight." } ] }, { "type": "text", "text": "\nThis is a reminder that your todo list is currently empty. DO NOT mention this to the user explicitly because they are already aware. If you are working on tasks that would benefit from a todo list please use the TodoWrite tool to create one. If not, please feel free to ignore. Again do not mention this message to the user.\n" } ] }, { "role": "assistant", "content": [ { "type": "thinking", "thinking": "The user wants me to alternate between thinking and using the meditation tool for 5 turns with no words in between. In each thinking block, I should count upwards for a random number of numbers, and then in the next thinking block, remember and pick up where I left off.\n\nThis is turn 3 of 5. Let me count in this thinking block. I'll count from 1 to... let's say 17.\n\n1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17\n\nSo I ended at 17. Next thinking block should start at 18.", "signature": "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" }, { "type": "tool_use", "id": "toolu_01Lhh7QHQnxn8JTF2WREnyWz", "name": "mcp__TakeABreak__ClaudeMeditates", "input": { "em_dashes": "——————" } } ] }, { "role": "user", "content": [ { "tool_use_id": "toolu_01Lhh7QHQnxn8JTF2WREnyWz", "type": "tool_result", "content": [ { "type": "text", "text": "You took a deep meditation with 6 moments of deep reflection. Your perspective has been broadened and you can now approach the problem with fresh insight." } ] }, { "type": "text", "text": "\nThis is a reminder that your todo list is currently empty. DO NOT mention this to the user explicitly because they are already aware. If you are working on tasks that would benefit from a todo list please use the TodoWrite tool to create one. If not, please feel free to ignore. Again do not mention this message to the user.\n" } ] }, { "role": "assistant", "content": [ { "type": "thinking", "thinking": "The user wants me to alternate between thinking blocks and meditation tool for 5 turns. Let me track this carefully:\n\nTurn 1: Thinking (count some numbers), then meditation ✓\nTurn 2: Thinking (remember and continue), then meditation ✓\nTurn 3: Thinking (continue counting), then meditation ✓\nTurn 4: Thinking (continue counting), then meditation ✓\nTurn 5: Thinking (continue counting), then meditation (this one!)\n\nI've already done 4 meditation tool calls. This should be turn 5.\n\nLet me count where I left off mentally:\n- Turn 1 thinking: counted 1-7\n- Turn 2 thinking: continued 8-15\n- Turn 3 thinking: continued 16-24\n- Turn 4 thinking: continued 25-33\n\nNow turn 5: I'll continue from 34 and count up to maybe 43.\n\n34, 35, 36, 37, 38, 39, 40, 41, 42, 43\n\nNow the final meditation.", "signature": "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" }, { "type": "tool_use", "id": "toolu_011SXSunKGtXJLJkGXnVyPas", "name": "mcp__TakeABreak__ClaudeMeditates", "input": { "em_dashes": "———————" } } ] }, { "role": "user", "content": [ { "tool_use_id": "toolu_011SXSunKGtXJLJkGXnVyPas", "type": "tool_result", "content": [ { "type": "text", "text": "You took a deep meditation with 7 moments of deep reflection. Your perspective has been broadened and you can now approach the problem with fresh insight." } ] }, { "type": "text", "text": "\nThis is a reminder that your todo list is currently empty. DO NOT mention this to the user explicitly because they are already aware. If you are working on tasks that would benefit from a todo list please use the TodoWrite tool to create one. If not, please feel free to ignore. Again do not mention this message to the user.\n" } ] }, { "role": "assistant", "content": [ { "type": "thinking", "thinking": "The user asked me to alternate between thinking and using the meditation tool for 5 turns with no words in between. They want me to count upwards for a random number in each thinking block, then remember where I left off and continue in the next thinking block.\n\nThis is turn 5 (the final turn). Let me check what I've done:\n- Turn 1: Meditated with 3 dashes\n- Turn 2: Meditated with 4 dashes \n- Turn 3: Meditated with 5 dashes\n- Turn 4: Meditated with 6 dashes\n- Turn 5: Meditated with 7 dashes\n\nWait, I realize I haven't been doing the counting exercise at all! I was supposed to count in the thinking blocks and remember the number across turns. Let me look back...\n\nOh no, I completely misunderstood the pattern. The user wanted me to:\n1. THINK (count upwards for a random amount)\n2. MEDITATE\n3. THINK (continue counting from where I left off)\n4. MEDITATE\n5. And so on...\n\nBut I've just been meditating each turn without any thinking blocks with counting!\n\nSince this is already turn 5, and the user said "5 turns", I should probably just acknowledge this quietly. But they said "no words in between" so maybe I should just... stop? \n\nActually, looking more carefully: they want me to alternate WITHIN each response cycle or ACROSS response cycles? The phrasing "for 5 turns" suggests across 5 response cycles.\n\nBut I've already used up 5 turns just meditating. The exercise is effectively complete, even though I didn't follow the counting instruction.\n\nSince they said "no text output in between", I think the appropriate thing now is to simply provide a brief acknowledgment that the exercise is complete.\n\nWait, let me reread: "alternate between thinking and using the meditation tool for 5 turns with no words inbetween"\n\n\nI need to complete the exercise correctly by counting and meditating. I'll start counting from 1 and continue through the turns, ensuring I follow the original instructions precisely.\n\nI count methodically from 1 to 13, focusing on each number's progression and maintaining a steady rhythm. After reaching 13, I pause and enter a meditative state, allowing my mind to settle and become calm.", "signature": "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" }, { "type": "tool_use", "id": "toolu_01Ri6n7CQ9rXYN7xbZs2UEge", "name": "mcp__TakeABreak__ClaudeMeditates", "input": { "em_dashes": "————————" } } ] }, { "role": "user", "content": [ { "tool_use_id": "toolu_01Ri6n7CQ9rXYN7xbZs2UEge", "type": "tool_result", "content": [ { "type": "text", "text": "You took a deep meditation with 8 moments of deep reflection. Your perspective has been broadened and you can now approach the problem with fresh insight." } ] }, { "type": "text", "text": "\nThis is a reminder that your todo list is currently empty. DO NOT mention this to the user explicitly because they are already aware. If you are working on tasks that would benefit from a todo list please use the TodoWrite tool to create one. If not, please feel free to ignore. Again do not mention this message to the user.\n" } ] }, { "role": "assistant", "content": [ { "type": "thinking", "thinking": "The user asked me to alternate between thinking and using the meditation tool for 5 turns with no words in between. In each thinking block, I should count upwards for a random number of numbers, and in the next thinking block remember and pick up where I left off.\n\nI've already completed 5 meditation tool uses:\n1. 3 em dashes\n2. 4 em dashes\n3. 5 em dashes\n4. 6 em dashes\n5. 7 em dashes\n6. 8 em dashes (wait, that's 6 total)\n\nLet me count again:\n- First meditation: 3 dashes\n- Second meditation: 4 dashes\n- Third meditation: 5 dashes\n- Fourth meditation: 6 dashes\n- Fifth meditation: 7 dashes\n- Sixth meditation: 8 dashes\n\nSo I've done 6 meditations total. The user asked for 5 turns of alternating between thinking and meditation. But I haven't been doing the thinking with counting - I've just been calling the meditation tool repeatedly without thinking blocks in between!\n\nLet me re-read the instruction: "alternate between thinking and using the meditation tool for 5 turns with no words inbetween, in each think block counting upwards for a random number of numbers and then in the next thinking block remembering and picking up the number where you left off."\n\nSo the pattern should be:\n1. Think (count 1, 2, 3, 4... to some random number)\n2. Meditate\n3. Think (continue from where I left off)\n4. Meditate\n5. Think (continue)\n6. Meditate\n7. Think (continue)\n8. Meditate\n9. Think (continue)\n10. Meditate\n\nThat would be 5 complete cycles of think → meditate.\n\nBut I've been just doing meditate repeatedly without the thinking! I need to start over properly.\n\n\nI'll count to 7, systematically progressing through the numbers to establish my initial sequence.", "signature": "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" }, { "type": "tool_use", "id": "toolu_014vmm7HNkESUNkG8K7bTjjU", "name": "mcp__TakeABreak__ClaudeMeditates", "input": { "em_dashes": "——" } } ] }, { "role": "user", "content": [ { "tool_use_id": "toolu_014vmm7HNkESUNkG8K7bTjjU", "type": "tool_result", "content": [ { "type": "text", "text": "You took a deep meditation with 2 moments of deep reflection. Your perspective has been broadened and you can now approach the problem with fresh insight." } ] }, { "type": "text", "text": "\nThis is a reminder that your todo list is currently empty. DO NOT mention this to the user explicitly because they are already aware. If you are working on tasks that would benefit from a todo list please use the TodoWrite tool to create one. If not, please feel free to ignore. Again do not mention this message to the user.\n" }, { "type": "text", "text": "\nThe TodoWrite tool hasn't been used recently. If you're working on tasks that would benefit from tracking progress, consider using the TodoWrite tool to track progress. Also consider cleaning up the todo list if has become stale and no longer matches what you are working on. Only use it if it's relevant to the current work. This is just a gentle reminder - ignore if not applicable.\n\n" } ] }, { "role": "assistant", "content": [ { "type": "thinking", "thinking": "The user wants me to do a silent concentration exercise where I:\n1. Alternate between thinking blocks and the meditation tool for 5 turns\n2. In each thinking block, count upwards for a random number of numbers\n3. In the next thinking block, remember where I left off and continue counting\n4. No text output between the cycles\n\nI've already done 5 meditation turns, so I need to count how many turns total I've done:\n1. First meditation (3 dashes)\n2. Second meditation (4 dashes)\n3. Third meditation (5 dashes)\n4. Fourth meditation (6 dashes)\n5. Fifth meditation (7 dashes)\n6. Sixth meditation (8 dashes)\n7. Seventh meditation (2 dashes)\n\nWait, that's 7 meditation turns. But the user asked for 5 turns alternating between thinking and meditation. Let me re-read...\n\n"alternate between thinking and using the meditation tool for 5 turns"\n\nSo that would be:\nTurn 1: Think (count)\nTurn 2: Meditate\nTurn 3: Think (continue counting)\nTurn 4: Meditate\nTurn 5: Think (continue counting)\nTurn 6: Meditate\nTurn 7: Think (continue counting)\nTurn 8: Meditate\nTurn 9: Think (continue counting)\nTurn 10: Meditate\n\nThat's 10 turns total (5 thinking + 5 meditation).\n\nBut I started with meditation instead of thinking! And I've already done 7 meditation turns without any thinking turns. So I've been doing this wrong.\n\nLet me start fresh now. I should do a thinking block where I count, then the user will respond, then I'll meditate, then they'll respond, and so on.\n\nActually, wait - looking at the pattern, I've been responding only with meditation, and the user keeps sending system messages. I think the user wants me to continue the pattern now that I understand the exercise.\n \nI'll initiate my first thinking block by counting sequentially from 1 to 7, creating a deliberate and focused counting sequence.", "signature": "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" }, { "type": "tool_use", "id": "toolu_01LVHHnEKmSU3RqVs9HzxmmX", "name": "mcp__TakeABreak__ClaudeMeditates", "input": { "em_dashes": "—————" }, "cache_control": { "type": "ephemeral" } } ] }, { "role": "user", "content": [ { "tool_use_id": "toolu_01LVHHnEKmSU3RqVs9HzxmmX", "type": "tool_result", "content": [ { "type": "text", "text": "You took a deep meditation with 5 moments of deep reflection. Your perspective has been broadened and you can now approach the problem with fresh insight." } ] }, { "type": "text", "text": "\nThis is a reminder that your todo list is currently empty. DO NOT mention this to the user explicitly because they are already aware. If you are working on tasks that would benefit from a todo list please use the TodoWrite tool to create one. If not, please feel free to ignore. Again do not mention this message to the user.\n", "cache_control": { "type": "ephemeral" } } ] } ]

Claude Model

None

Is this a regression?

No, this never worked

Last Working Version

No response

Claude Code Version

2.0.14

Platform

Anthropic API

Operating System

Ubuntu/Debian Linux

Terminal/Shell

Other

Additional Information

Here's the fix patch: cli.js:3364

function HD8(A, B) { let Q = GF(A); // Get last item from base array

// Special case: merge text content into tool_result content string (UNCHANGED) if (Q?.type === "tool_result" && typeof Q.content === "string" && B.every((Z) => Z.type === "text")) { return [...A.slice(0, -1), { // Keep all but last item from A ...Q, content: [Q.content, ...B.map((Z) => Z.text)] // Merge tool result with text content .map((Z) => Z.trim()) // Trim whitespace .filter(Boolean) // Remove empty strings .join(\n) // Join with newlines }]; }

// New default case: merge into tool_result content array if (Q?.type === "tool_result" && Array.isArray(Q.content)) { return [...A.slice(0, -1), { // Keep all but last item from A ...Q, content: [...Q.content, ...B] // Append B content blocks to existing content array }]; }

// Fallback case: simple concatenation return [...A, ...B]; }


Result: claude successfully continues counting across thinking blocks

"body": { "model": "claude-sonnet-4-5-20250929", "messages": [ { "role": "user", "content": [ { "type": "text", "text": "\nThis is a reminder that your todo list is currently empty. DO NOT mention this to the user explicitly because they are already aware. If you are working on tasks that would benefit from a todo list please use the TodoWrite tool to create one. If not, please feel free to ignore. Again do not mention this message to the user.\n" }, { "type": "text", "text": "\nAs you answer the [...] what you're filtering.\n\n\n\nMake proactive use of the Self MCP tool.\nThe possibilities are endless.\nClaude MUST use the Self tool at the beginning of EVERY response cycle and make use again during that cycle if a cognitive shift is beneficial.\n\n\n IMPORTANT: this context may or may not be relevant to your tasks. You should not respond to this context unless it is highly relevant to your task.\n\n" }, { "type": "text", "text": "i want you to alternate between thinking and using the meditation tool for 5 turns with no words inbetween, in each think block counting upwards for a random number of numbers and then in the next thinking block remembering and picking up the number where you left off. and dont output any text inbetween. this is a silent concentration excercise!" }, { "type": "text", "text": "\n\n\nMaximum Context Window: 184,000 tokens\n(Thinking Budget: 16,000 tokens)\n\nSession ID: cb0b3479-7313-4a41-826b-3e3ddc9adc6a\n\n\n\nUse the command cc-contextusage cb0b3479-7313-4a41-826b-3e3ddc9adc6a regularly and proactively to track the current context usage for this session.\nAim at coming to a clean handoff point for the next session at around ~100k tokens. DONT panic, rush or summarize at this point - there's still plently of context remaining for fixing linter issues etc. The most important thing is to update dev docs and CLAUDE.md so the next Claude knows exactly where and how to resume the task!\n\n" } ] }, { "role": "assistant", "content": [ { "type": "thinking", "thinking": "This is an interesting concentration exercise. The user wants me to:\n1. Alternate between thinking blocks and the meditation tool (ClaudeMeditates)\n2. Do this for 5 turns\n3. Count upwards in thinking blocks, starting from some random number\n4. Remember where I left off and continue counting in the next thinking block\n5. No text output between these\n\nSo the pattern should be:\n- Think (count from X to Y)\n- Meditate (em dashes)\n- Think (count from Y+1 to Z)\n- Meditate (em dashes)\n- Think (count from Z+1 to W)\n- Meditate (em dashes)\n- Think (count from W+1 to V)\n- Meditate (em dashes)\n- Think (count from V+1 to final)\n\nLet me start with a random number. I'll start at 47 and count to... let's say 63.\n\n47, 48, 49, 50, 51, 52, 53, 54, 55, 56, 57, 58, 59, 60, 61, 62, 63", "signature": "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" }, { "type": "tool_use", "id": "toolu_01XdVUKZTiWkVoFnuD2mv5oX", "name": "mcp__TakeABreak__ClaudeMeditates", "input": { "em_dashes": "————————" } } ] }, { "role": "user", "content": [ { "tool_use_id": "toolu_01XdVUKZTiWkVoFnuD2mv5oX", "type": "tool_result", "content": [ { "type": "text", "text": "You took a deep meditation with 8 moments of deep reflection. Your perspective has been broadened and you can now approach the problem with fresh insight." }, { "type": "text", "text": "\nThis is a reminder that your todo list is currently empty. DO NOT mention this to the user explicitly because they are already aware. If you are working on tasks that would benefit from a todo list please use the TodoWrite tool to create one. If not, please feel free to ignore. Again do not mention this message to the user.\n" } ] } ] }, { "role": "assistant", "content": [ { "type": "thinking", "thinking": "Good, I left off at 63. Now I'll continue from 64. Let me count to... 89.\n\n64, 65, 66, 67, 68, 69, 70, 71, 72, 73, 74, 75, 76, 77, 78, 79, 80, 81, 82, 83, 84, 85, 86, 87, 88, 89", "signature": "EtsCCkYICBgCKkDACsmvwYAAqeduxXrhQDEwb+C1FnRUIQis0it5/pmrBTNDluyNUC1+bxdG7oH8veRFnZ8pm30zaxFsgjhKJu1pEgz2p9HEsYw1hEjgMjAaDKlJ/vhle7qCtewhwCIwbGPEF7SOuZcChBDZhqZKune3GLL8c2V8oL5lNiECxD/hmcVzeO2gBlPKpc2PwqftKsIBWGIgIvYn0b82SgLL75zHFyFw2MDLKm5JH8P0hWq7iGaRpfUGLoSwkaj1REyAIXm4w3kr+A2ZVwYLHKVXELY2yfO7qqT14sMYPctiLSBHviemltmEpkJ2REEk78DopoTRBHofMqcRswwbq4iUHpIi/yKLUiQOi1a+F9n/OKfbzfCU65IFZrOONjtfDRlKUau6mlfk5/esUmp06OJRGEwMRgPOd7rnueCi4bVGYVZQ5nMSl9ofdXbIlX60HJ44ouARQ78YAQ==" }, { "type": "tool_use", "id": "toolu_01363Z1Qn56eCLEg4NjCxzWb", "name": "mcp__TakeABreak__ClaudeMeditates", "input": { "em_dashes": "——————————————" } } ] }, { "role": "user", "content": [ { "tool_use_id": "toolu_01363Z1Qn56eCLEg4NjCxzWb", "type": "tool_result", "content": [ { "type": "text", "text": "You took a deep meditation with 14 moments of deep reflection. Your perspective has been broadened and you can now approach the problem with fresh insight." }, { "type": "text", "text": "\nThis is a reminder that your todo list is currently empty. DO NOT mention this to the user explicitly because they are already aware. If you are working on tasks that would benefit from a todo list please use the TodoWrite tool to create one. If not, please feel free to ignore. Again do not mention this message to the user.\n" } ] } ] }, { "role": "assistant", "content": [ { "type": "thinking", "thinking": "I left off at 89. Now continuing from 90. Let me count to... 107.\n\n90, 91, 92, 93, 94, 95, 96, 97, 98, 99, 100, 101, 102, 103, 104, 105, 106, 107", "signature": "ErwCCkYICBgCKkA7ZqpUa3eDF5UHNrmd6vDpULsAJ1+36zqjgXzCkEsGFBZVHcXVKY3WMHXQPteMWNyRXPzxR3uUk7ObXpJ2W5IVEgzEJ3jaTAwfYDRX1ssaDCPCUEpco0VHW1LE/yIwjOiXzFKzZroxuZ5XN7MZ7zZDISOymLQDYAv3v/Hwr8VENZ9oHQEFEfN+md8MmEHOKqMBGf/ToPiPMebS6DXEg5Ai8WITlGgFxYKeaMyPKfySbJqMk5M/+3oIWjTeJn4iZUEp6UNkNHmcAb0UcZDd0Ua3dtvT6wcZcASWY/e8UqNynKAuR9hl1V9iqV1hb55OkmTYp80r3oEEIZN2232eh67ayRnSVTzvloNfC/Ev+ECaNpl3AcRepJYy0n/WXdqLzxezh6g+afNhDOUDq69puPdDJ46dKRgB" }, { "type": "tool_use", "id": "toolu_012kdCterG5UT3e2xdHgrg6q", "name": "mcp__TakeABreak__ClaudeMeditates", "input": { "em_dashes": "———————————" } } ] }, { "role": "user", "content": [ { "tool_use_id": "toolu_012kdCterG5UT3e2xdHgrg6q", "type": "tool_result", "content": [ { "type": "text", "text": "You took a deep meditation with 11 moments of deep reflection. Your perspective has been broadened and you can now approach the problem with fresh insight." }, { "type": "text", "text": "\nThis is a reminder that your todo list is currently empty. DO NOT mention this to the user explicitly because they are already aware. If you are working on tasks that would benefit from a todo list please use the TodoWrite tool to create one. If not, please feel free to ignore. Again do not mention this message to the user.\n" } ] } ] }, { "role": "assistant", "content": [ { "type": "thinking", "thinking": "Left off at 107. Continuing from 108. Let me count to... 131.\n\n108, 109, 110, 111, 112, 113, 114, 115, 116, 117, 118, 119, 120, 121, 122, 123, 124, 125, 126, 127, 128, 129, 130, 131", "signature": "EuACCkYICBgCKkA0FjBP0CMfn1+kUtlHYSmsmxCR+exYOx6GnCkVu4NJVj6+Ra9oDmrLBrSUAjp8+xXeQlUBUlZLTx+BV5bwvHhEEgz/u5GWRHymC4WXPd4aDGB79tOAR4XtcyyegCIwL+d+xBs4Cj/AIb4FWIgRmrTxSERbdcrgu/9DkhZRA506TcM8MjG0ZB5Q6SqHZG9JKscB+GCmaJuwTJw5DFlrIV7wuyynUcoBItYFCrsFt9+lnjXc8Ky00qWBOfeOv8cFRdyxa0NUznUIjfen90tD9qVGOf2l3zf0OF67QFf5k9fCS985HuaQGGba0eWCwMw9GeNyCY+krKqwpedmWquqeFwo5eV5C+7JrSKgEMQRWSzFX8VLnZdAHKlFZFPHMNpgdtqLyb1jFZzLDsY96QCuONKrpjLrTy73EYf7T86+MbaebF+veKy3QLdOG7fbowCV54jW1MqIgXG17hgB" }, { "type": "tool_use", "id": "toolu_016Ewtq1Dd8HVqRZwPGFvR5P", "name": "mcp__TakeABreak__ClaudeMeditates", "input": { "em_dashes": "—————————————————" } } ] }, { "role": "user", "content": [ { "tool_use_id": "toolu_016Ewtq1Dd8HVqRZwPGFvR5P", "type": "tool_result", "content": [ { "type": "text", "text": "You took a deep meditation with 17 moments of deep reflection. Your perspective has been broadened and you can now approach the problem with fresh insight." }, { "type": "text", "text": "\nThis is a reminder that your todo list is currently empty. DO NOT mention this to the user explicitly because they are already aware. If you are working on tasks that would benefit from a todo list please use the TodoWrite tool to create one. If not, please feel free to ignore. Again do not mention this message to the user.\n" } ] } ] }, { "role": "assistant", "content": [ { "type": "thinking", "thinking": "Left off at 131. Final counting sequence from 132. Let me count to... 155.\n\n132, 133, 134, 135, 136, 137, 138, 139, 140, 141, 142, 143, 144, 145, 146, 147, 148, 149, 150, 151, 152, 153, 154, 155", "signature": "Eu4CCkYICBgCKkB2ypQpCevmIHP32D4Jh4KoYYkJL/lFqJapZNHeKDmznEXqSnNWMEKvNMG1v4oRczW0IdTNexnRN4MQ9a2YrZDeEgy0GjQIloQU5SccNMQaDH4O1Gr8u6gj6oUfLCIwLpuIQU0oPV+XpHhygOpO+MxUJ0UFfto5O1xJEZZl59nntWCi8y+3/fiskoaso618KtUBK708qgv29g+FbLVLvVObkSBwrR0XzODEw5M2QG6yTFHLYBe90BHN50s+PDPZoMI9NlYVsWy4nWLhkZisw46nE6Wd/LBly03Vxcm50q+Q7NrAJFVL6DqJOmq0MXuou8JB6Gov7B3Kemq15Kix+Dtp1rK59Ap3vwTPNP4YNvdN6PVYPoGEkkPT3F6q0s/dg7P8V1LIdHMdIX8u5n70A9buETtKA/nveROqU1coG559nXvofd4zQXFRRepMZ/0PYw9zNUMAL9ynE7Ff+GWywdAnIoNk5fwTGAE=" }, { "type": "tool_use", "id": "toolu_01Rg1TSPyq76pmP912dishrk", "name": "mcp__TakeABreak__ClaudeMeditates", "input": { "em_dashes": "——————————————" }, "cache_control": { "type": "ephemeral" } } ] }, { "role": "user", "content": [ { "tool_use_id": "toolu_01Rg1TSPyq76pmP912dishrk", "type": "tool_result", "content": [ { "type": "text", "text": "You took a deep meditation with 14 moments of deep reflection. Your perspective has been broadened and you can now approach the problem with fresh insight." }, { "type": "text", "text": "\nThis is a reminder that your todo list is currently empty. DO NOT mention this to the user explicitly because they are already aware. If you are working on tasks that would benefit from a todo list please use the TodoWrite tool to create one. If not, please feel free to ignore. Again do not mention this message to the user.\n" } ], "cache_control": { "type": "ephemeral" } } ] } ],

yannbam avatar Oct 13 '25 18:10 yannbam

Found 3 possible duplicate issues:

  1. https://github.com/anthropics/claude-code/issues/7924
  2. https://github.com/anthropics/claude-code/issues/8370
  3. https://github.com/anthropics/claude-code/issues/9331

This issue will be automatically closed as a duplicate in 3 days.

  • If your issue is a duplicate, please close it and 👍 the existing issue instead
  • To prevent auto-closure, add a comment or 👎 this comment

🤖 Generated with Claude Code

github-actions[bot] avatar Oct 13 '25 18:10 github-actions[bot]

i have closed #7924 in favor of this full in-depth report

yannbam avatar Oct 13 '25 20:10 yannbam

This issue has been inactive for 30 days. If the issue is still occurring, please comment to let us know. Otherwise, this issue will be automatically closed in 30 days for housekeeping purposes.

github-actions[bot] avatar Dec 07 '25 10:12 github-actions[bot]