namada icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
namada copied to clipboard

Unable to Become Steward Despite Successful Vote on Removal and Addition of Steward

Open tphat2616 opened this issue 1 year ago • 2 comments

Issue description:

I encountered a bug where I voted to remove the steward from one address and add myself as a steward in its place. However, the address I wished to remove from steward is currently not listed as a steward. Despite my vote passing, I am unable to become a steward.

Steps to Reproduce:

Query the proposal:

namadac query-proposal --proposal-id 382

Review the proposal details:

Proposal Id: 382 Type: PGF steward Author: tnam1qppwtk3sp08gg9j60sqa3gmxn3q5pzn25s5hpccl Content: {"abstract": "Anoma for Steward for life", "authors": "Anoma Foundation", "created": "2024-01-01T00:00:01Z", "details": "Anoma should be a good and worthy steward", "discussions-to": "Anoma also a Steward", "license": "MIT", "motivation": "There are no other candidates currently so I should win !", "title": "It's a Beautiful Life with Namada"} Start Epoch: 50 End Epoch: 54 Grace Epoch: 56 Status: ended

Data:

Addresses: Add(tnam1qppwtk3sp08gg9j60sqa3gmxn3q5pzn25s5hpccl) Remove(tnam1qpfdghevjctmk5nyvm8yecnltwxk9k0fgqhntys2) Remove(tnam1qqnarl4h6dsy4jchy0tcxakh286ec03weyfnks6e)

Expected Behavior:

Upon successfully passing the vote, I should become a steward after the removal and addition process, regardless of the current status of the address I wished to remove stewardship from.

Actual Behavior:

Despite the successful vote, I am unable to become a steward.

Additional Information:

This issue is critical as it impacts the functionality of the steward system. Any assistance in resolving this bug would be greatly appreciated.

tphat2616 avatar Apr 11 '24 03:04 tphat2616

Changes take effect once grace epoch ends (i.e. once the next epoch begins).

McDaan avatar Apr 11 '24 06:04 McDaan

Changes take effect once grace epoch ends (i.e. once the next epoch begins).

Sorry, but you seemly don't under what I've raised. Please read this carefully.

tphat2616 avatar Apr 12 '24 08:04 tphat2616