1g1r-romset-generator icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
1g1r-romset-generator copied to clipboard

Redump DAT support

Open Otakufanatic opened this issue 3 years ago • 5 comments

Congratulations for this excellent tool for the no-intro sets, which are the reference for consoles in cartridge format. Is another tool possible for the redump sets which are the reference in CD format?

Best regards,

Retrofan.

Otakufanatic avatar Sep 18 '20 16:09 Otakufanatic

I have to look into it, but I have this other tool in the works, which should be able to be more easily extended to process data from other DAT formats.

https://github.com/andrebrait/DATROMTool

andrebrait avatar Sep 18 '20 17:09 andrebrait

So, it turns out redump uses the same format, despite handling disks.

You can likely already use this tool for that.

andrebrait avatar Sep 22 '20 22:09 andrebrait

but the redump dat doesn't include the parents-clones, I don't think it works well...

Otakufanatic avatar Sep 28 '20 16:09 Otakufanatic

I see. In this case, there's not much I can do. The parent-clone relationship has to be curated by humans and filled in the DAT. It's the only reliable way I can know game A is a clone of game B. Matching by name and other approaches don't work because you can't really match, say, Lylat Wars and Star Fox, even though they're the same game.

If redump doesn't include parent-clone information, you can't generate a 1G1R using them.

andrebrait avatar Sep 28 '20 16:09 andrebrait

I found some resources on the matter and I'll be looking into them for the next tool I'm writing.

https://github.com/unexpectedpanda/retool https://forums.launchbox-app.com/topic/54331-redump-1g1r-collection-tool-disc-systems-ps-psp-xbox-gc-dreamcast-etc/

andrebrait avatar Sep 28 '20 16:09 andrebrait