technicalindicators icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
technicalindicators copied to clipboard

diffrence with tradingview and this RSI calculation

Open masoudnfd opened this issue 3 years ago • 5 comments

Hi I read https://github.com/anandanand84/technicalindicators/issues/216 but my problem was not solved .

closePrice = [ 46183.55, 46116.61, 46412.41, 45974.08, 46307.49, 45713.94, 45721.52, 46092.6, 45882.54, 45839.4, 46283.24, 46429.19, 46557.32, 46433.18, 46967.48, 46687.22, 46731.84, 46619.56, 46880.83, 46681.23, 47296.66, 46730.35, 46776.39, 46673.93, 47121.57, 47141.22, 47162.04, 47239.8, 47393.2, 47629.95, 47256.64, 47152.72, 47125.01, 47102.02, 47473.06, 47515.09, 47484.32, 47600, 47892.73, 47712.38, 47150.01, 46579.22, 46664.34, 46834.48, 46773.84, 46948.38, 46864.56, 46643.68, 46726.37, 46665.13, 46799.94, 46858.55, 47009.02, 46639.22, 47035.5, 47070.44, 47309.57, 46841.63, 46335.69, 46364.08, 46332.38, 46592.29, 46395.9, 46283.05, 45696.23, 45661.11, 46314.87, 46131.2, 46555.42, 46852.91, 46183.92, 46765.66, 46989.28, 46761.71, 47077.3, 46528.83, 45971.01, 46950.03, 47039.43, 47112.43, 46954.96, 47228.94, 47136.35, 47007.25, 47419.95, 47702.81, 47913.02, 47766.07, 47810.01, 47848.33, 47789.74, 47632.38, 47821.27, 48089.61, 47929.53, 47866.01, 47983.5, 48084.14, 48506.58, 48585.81 ]

rsiCalcualte = [ 60.2, 55.72, 56.28, 54.42, 57.9, 54.48, 61.95, 53.28, 53.85, 52.33, 57.91, 58.14, 58.4, 59.42, 61.43, 64.36, 57.01, 55.12, 54.6, 54.14, 59.95, 60.56, 59.84, 61.68, 65.94, 61.41, 49.92, 41.44, 42.99, 46.08, 45.14, 48.39, 46.95, 43.3, 45.02, 43.96, 46.94, 48.23, 51.49, 44.13, 52.04, 52.67, 56.89, 47.9, 40.46, 41.01, 40.56, 45.85, 42.75, 41.04, 33.51, 33.12, 45.81, 43.32, 50.07, 54.18, 45.17, 52.56, 55.07, 52.05, 55.68, 48.77, 42.94, 53.46, 54.29, 54.99, 53.09, 55.95, 54.73, 53.01, 57.61, 60.46, 62.48, 60.17, 60.64, 61.07, 59.99, 57.06, 59.61, 62.97, 59.77, 58.5, 60.19, 61.62, 67, 67.91, 66.68, 71.91, 64.55, 69.96, 68.65, 64.36, 60.6, 59.52, 62.03, 54.44, 57.79, 58.87, 61.52, 61.77 ],

but TradingView and MetaTrader data is = [46.16 , 45.23 , 49.18 , 42.25 , 46.75 , ....]

How can I get results equivalent to TradingView or MetaTrader?

masoudnfd avatar Dec 20 '21 18:12 masoudnfd

Have you checked that you are using the same periods?

rishikesh2003 avatar Dec 25 '21 10:12 rishikesh2003

yes the RSI formula is wrong in this package

masoudnfd avatar Dec 26 '21 10:12 masoudnfd

Can you share your code?

rishikesh2003 avatar Dec 26 '21 11:12 rishikesh2003

Sorry for my english.

try to use an array with 90 elements for calculation. In my case, the RSI of 14 periods is exactly the same as the trading view. I tried using trading-signals lib, but they are very, very, very slow, but the result is the same.

On Sun, Dec 26, 2021 at 8:33 AM Rishikesh S @.***> wrote:

Can you share your code?

— Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/anandanand84/technicalindicators/issues/248#issuecomment-1001160656, or unsubscribe https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AA3Q3NBUXBEVSYSDGRYJZ6TUS34O3ANCNFSM5KOKW2GQ . You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread.Message ID: @.***>

denernun avatar Dec 26 '21 17:12 denernun

RSI calculate true, im using this packages without errors

ikulichkov avatar Jan 18 '22 04:01 ikulichkov