amesgen

> I have not yet seen any quantification of the problem or the proposed solution. I think this is a necessary prerequisite for governance approval so that people can evaluate...

> @amesgen that's great! So do you think it's a fair headline to say that best case, there's a 2.6% financial benefit to some of the smaller pools? Yes, while...

Minor comments: > Note that this use is *exactly contrary* to the warning comments where `allegraProtVer` is actually set, such as: > > https://github.com/input-output-hk/cardano-node/blob/70dde196367e86c977fbe72167f4eb303b3ffa88/cardano-node/src/Cardano/Node/Protocol/Cardano.hs#L185-L194 Yeah, I think this is a...

> what should happen in the case that the blessed `GenTxId` era is disabled in the config? should we pick another era arbitrarily? should there be a way to order...

> does picking Shelley have any other risks that would be relevant? I can't think of anything; everything that uses our code shouldn't care about this at all due to...

> It can't have extra deps files like gemset.nix (ruby) or deps.nix (go) In principle, would you be interested in/open to relaxing this?

Yes, but isn't the problem that nixpkgs-update doesn't find the old version in the main `.nix` file, and hence won't proceed in opening a PR? For example, for `cddl`, which...